|
|
||||||||
Original Research Communications |
1 From the Department of Nutrition and Program in International Nutrition, University of California, Davis, and the Department of Nutrition and Food Science, University of Ghana, Legon.
2 Supported by the Nestlé Foundation, a Rockefeller Foundation African Dissertation Internship Award (to AM), and a Fulbright Scholarship from the Fulbright Program, USIA (to AL). The Clinical Nutrition Research Unit (with grant NIH-NIDDK 35747) at the University of California, Davis, analyzed the blood samples and Roche Vitamins and Fine Chemicals donated the vitamin-mineral premix.
3 Reprints not available. Address correspondence to KG Dewey, Department of Nutrition and Program in International Nutrition, University of California, One Shields Avenue, Davis, CA 95616-8669. E-mail: kgdewey{at}ucdavis.edu.,
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Objective: We evaluated the effect of feeding Weanimix and 3 other locally formulated, centrally processed complementary foods on the nutritional status of 208 breast-fed infants.
Design: Infants were randomly assigned to receive 1 of 4 foods from 6 to 12 mo of age: Weanimix (W), Weanimix plus vitamins and minerals (WM), Weanimix plus fish powder (WF), and koko plus fish powder (KF). Dietary and anthropometric data were collected regularly. Blood was collected at 6 and 12 mo of age to assess iron, zinc, vitamin A, and riboflavin status. Before and after the intervention, cross-sectional data on the anthropometric status of infants not included in the intervention (NI; n = 464) were collected.
Results: There were no significant differences between intervention groups in weight or length gain or in hemoglobin, hematocrit, transferrin saturation, plasma zinc, or erythrocyte riboflavin values between 6 and 12 mo of age. From 9 to 12 mo of age, z scores were lower in NI infants than in the combined intervention groups [at 12 mo: -1.71 ± 0.90 compared with -1.19 ± 0.93 for weight and -1.27 ± 1.02 compared with -0.63 ± 0.84 for length (P < 0.001 for both), respectively]. The percentage of infants with low ferritin values increased significantly between 6 and 12 mo of age in groups W, WF, and KF but not in group WM. Change in plasma retinol between 6 and 12 mo of age was significantly greater in group WM than in the other 3 groups combined (0.14 ± 0.3 compared with -0.04 ± 0.3 µmol/L, P = 0.003).
Conclusions: All 4 foods improved growth relative to the NI group. Infants fed WM had better iron stores and vitamin A status than those fed nonfortified foods.
Key Words: Complementary feeding breast-feeding infant growth micronutrient status iron zinc vitamin A riboflavin Ghana energy density Weanimix koko fermented maize porridge
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
1 wk for daily use by the household. The dough can also be purchased in a ready-to-use form from local markets. The availability, minimal cost, and ease of preparation make koko the preferred complementary food for the majority of Ghanaian infants. However, koko, like many traditional weaning foods in developing countries, has low energy and nutrient density (8), and has been implicated in the development of protein-energy malnutrition in infants (9). In an effort to improve the quality of weaning food, the Ghanaian Ministry of Health Nutrition Division and the United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF/Ghana) in 1987 introduced Weanimix, a cereal-legume blend, as an alternative. Weanimix is composed of 1015% soybeans or cowpeas, 10% groundnuts (peanuts) and 7580% maize (corn). Although Weanimix is an improvement over koko with respect to its energy and protein density, it has high phytate and fiber contents (estimated phytate-iron and phytate-zinc molar ratios of 7.3 and 17, respectively), which may impair iron and zinc absorption (10, 11). In addition, it is low in vitamin A (0.36 mg retinol equivalent/kg) and riboflavin (0.4 mg/kg). Before its promotion, no intervention trial had been undertaken to assess its effect on growth and micronutrient status of infants. Furthermore, results of a study with weanling rats (21 d old) raised questions about its ability to support adequate growth (12). The weight gain (30 ± 2 g) of rats fed Weanimix for 28 d was similar to that of rats fed an iron-deficient 20%-casein diet (23 ± 10 g) and lower than that of rats fed a casein diet with 12 mg Fe/kg (82 ± 10 g). Rats fed fermented maize dough gained only 10 ± 2 g, whereas those fed fermented maize dough plus 20% fish powder gained 113 ± 13 g (P < 0.05).
The present study was designed to compare the growth and micronutrient (iron, zinc, riboflavin, and vitamin A) status of Ghanaian infants 612 mo of age fed Weanimix (W) or 1 of 3 other improved complementary foods, namely: Weanimix with vitamins and minerals added (WM), Weanimix with fish powder (WF), or koko with fish powder (KF). Fish powder (from anchovies), a relatively cheap and available ingredient in most households, was added to Weanimix and koko to study whether it could be used as a fortificant to improve the nutrient quality of these complementary foods. The main hypothesis was that children fed WM, WF, or KF would have significantly better growth and iron, zinc, and riboflavin status than infants fed unmodified Weanimix.
| SUBJECTS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
400 km north of Accra. Techiman is a district capital with a population of
45000 and has the largest market in Ghana. The main occupations are farming and trading. The Brong Ahafo region is one of the major food-growing regions of the country. Foods grown include yam, cassava, plantain, maize, beans, and other vegetables. Most households keep domestic animals such as chickens, goats, and sheep. The so-called hungry season (DecemberApril) is relatively short in the Brong Ahafo region compared with the northern regions of the country where dry climatic conditions and a short rainy period result in longer periods of drought. Although malaria is endemic year-round in Ghana, the incidence is highest in the wet season (JuneAugust) with the peak incidence in July (13). A pilot study we conducted in 1993 on infant-feeding practices in Techiman showed that breast-feeding was almost universal and >90% of infants were fed koko by 3 mo of age. The median duration of breast-feeding in the region is 23 mo (14). The source of water for most households is dug-hole well water.
Study design
The study had 2 parts: the main longitudinal trial (a randomized intervention) and a cross-sectional study of the nutritional status of nonintervention infants. For the longitudinal study, infants <1 mo of age were recruited between November 1994 and April 1995; all of them had reached 12 mo of age by March 1996. Cross-sectional data on infants 612 mo of age were collected both before (JulyAugust 1993) and after (AprilSept 1996) the longitudinal study.
Longitudinal trial
Preparation of diets
The Weanimix used in this study consisted of 75% maize (corn), 15% soybeans, and 10% groundnuts (peanuts). The whole ingredients were roasted separately, mixed, and milled. WM was formulated to meet or exceed the vitamin and mineral requirements of infants when consumed with typical volumes of breast milk. Nutrients were added directly to the W flour; we used a vitamin-mineral premix (TSD #10781) from Roche Vitamins and Fine Chemicals (Nutley, NJ) plus additional iron (electrolytic iron), potassium (as potassium citrate), calcium, and phosphorus (as dicalcium phosphate) to meet the target amounts. To avoid potential toxicity problems, 2 levels of fortification were used, the higher one for infants consuming
60 g W/d and the lower one for infants consuming >60 g/d (Table 1
). The fish powder was prepared from smoked anchovies purchased in bulk from the local market in Techiman. The head, scales, and intestines were discarded. The remaining parts were dried in a solar dryer and milled into powder by using a plate mill. For the WF, the fish powder was added to W at 20% by weight. In the preparation of KF, the fermented maize dough was prepared from dry maize by using traditional methods (7). The resulting dough was dehydrated in a drum dryer and ground into fine flour. To this flour, fish powder was added at 20% by weight. All the diets were centrally processed and were packaged into 500-g packets by the Techiman Weaning Food Project; which is privately owned, operates under the Sunyani Catholic diocese, and produces W for sale within the region.
|
Before these foods were used in the intervention study, acceptability trials were conducted with 34 infants 612 mo of age. In these trials, each mother was given one of the project foods to prepare a porridge suitable for feeding her infant (n = 10 for W, 5 for WM, 7 for WF, and 12 for KF). The trials were conducted at a central facility in the presence of project assistants. The food was considered acceptable to the infant if at least some of the food was consumed; each of the 34 infants consumed some of their assigned project food. The average amount consumed was one-half to three-fourths of the amount offered (250 g) for all 4 foods. Feedback from mothers after the feeding trials indicated their willingness to feed the project foods to their infants.
Intervention
Infants
1 mo (n = 216) were recruited from Maternal and Child Health centers run by the Techiman Ministry of Health. Selection criteria were as follows: birth weight
2.5 kg, breast-fed, no congenital abnormalities, assigned a Maternal and Child Health card, and the child's mother was not planning to travel or move out of study area during the study period. Informed consent was given by both parents or the mother alone in the case of single mothers. The study was approved by the Human Subjects Review Committee of the University of California, Davis, and the Ministry of Health, Ghana.
At the time of recruitment, baseline data on the study households were collected and mothers were given advice on infant-feeding practices and encouraged to breast-feed exclusively for the first 6 mo. Between the ages of 1 and 6 mo, monthly anthropometric measurements were taken (weight, length, triceps and subscapular skinfold thicknesses, and midupper arm and head circumferences). Information on infant-feeding practices and morbidity data were collected monthly.
Eight infants dropped out before 6 mo of age, 7 because the parents moved out of the study area, and 1 because the father refused participation. At 6 mo of age, infants who remained eligible (n = 208) were randomly assigned to receive 1 of the 4 foods to be fed from 6 to 12 mo of age. Random assignment to treatment groups was done as follows: 35 blocks of varying sizes (4, 8, or 12 subjects) were created and randomly shuffled. Within each block, subjects were assigned to the 4 treatment groups in equal numbers. At 6 mo of age, subjects were assigned to the next value on the list as they entered the study. The result of this randomization scheme was that the subjects were equally assigned among groups over time, but the investigators could not predict to what treatment the next subject would be assigned.
The prepackaged complementary foods were supplied to mothers weekly (500 g/wk) without charge. Mothers were encouraged to feed the project foods
3 times/d but they were free to feed other foods. To reduce problems of contamination through unhygienic handling and storage of the porridge, all mothers were given a vacuum flask in which to store the prepared porridge and were educated on how to maintain the flask.
Food intake.
Intake of project and nonproject foods was monitored by monthly 24-h recalls for 3 d (2 weekdays and 1 weekend day) at 6, 7, 8, 10, and 12 mo. In addition, 12-h weighed food records were completed for
50% of subjects randomly selected at each of the same ages. For the latter method, an observer weighed all foods and beverages consumed by the infant during a 12-h period. Energy and nutrient intakes from foods were calculated by using FOOD PROCESSOR PLUS software (ESHA Research, Salem, OR), local food-composition tables, values published elsewhere (8, 15), and, for project foods, analyzed values for fat, iron, zinc, and riboflavin.
Anthropometry.
Birth weights were recorded mostly from birth certificates. Because birth length is not routinely measured in hospitals in Ghana, 2 trained assistants recorded birth weights and birth lengths of infants born in the 2 major maternity facilities in Techiman (Holy Family Hospital and Armstrong Maternity Home) during the 5-mo recruitment period. Of these infants, those who were eligible by 1 mo of age were recruited for the study (n = 70). Other infants, born at these facilities or elsewhere who were eligible by 1 mo of age but for whom birth length was not measured, were also recruited. In these cases, birth weight was recorded from birth records, and birth length was missing. We examined the validity of the birth weights obtained from records by checking the correlation with weight at 1 mo (r = 0.61). Birth weight measured by project assistants also correlated with weight at 1 mo (r = 0.69).
Anthropometric measurements (weight, length, triceps and subscapular skinfold thicknesses, and midupper arm and head circumferences) were taken monthly until 12 mo of age. Infants were weighed naked (to the nearest 100 g) on a digital infant scale (Perspective Enterprises, Portage, MI). Recumbent length was measured to the nearest 0.1 cm on a portable infant measuring board (Perspective Enterprises). Triceps and subscapular skinfold-thickness measurements were taken on the left side to the nearest 0.1 mm by using Holtain skinfold calipers (Crymych, United Kingdom), and midupper arm and head circumferences were measured to the nearest 0.1 cm by using an insertion tape. Maternal weight was measured monthly (to the nearest 0.2 kg) and height (to the nearest 0.1 cm) was also measured at baseline. Anthropometric measurements were taken by 2 trained assistants whose techniques were standardized according to World Health Organization procedures (16). Measurements were completed at Maternal and Child Health centers when mothers reported with their infants for the regular monthly growth monitoring. Absentees were measured in their homes within 1 d. Weight and length measurements of infants were converted to z scores by using National Center for Health Statistics (NCHS) reference values (17). Midupper arm fat area (MAFA) and midupper arm muscle area (MAMA) were calculated by using the following equations (18, 19):
|
| (1) |
|
| (2) |
where TSF is triceps skinfold thickness (mm) and C is midupper arm circumference (mm).
Clinical chemistry measurements.
At baseline (6 mo) and at 12 mo of age, 5 mL blood was collected by venipuncture from all infants. Hemoglobin concentration and hematocrit were determined within 15 min of blood collection. Infants with hemoglobin concentrations <90 g/L (n = 28 at 12 mo) were given medicinal iron drops (12 mg Fe in 5 mL daily for 2 mo). Plasma was separated and was kept frozen at -20°C until analyzed. The red blood cells were washed 3 times in saline solution (0.9% NaCl), centrifuged at 1380 x g at room temperature for 15 min, and the supernate was discarded. The cells were kept frozen at -20°C. Samples were transported to the Clinical Nutrition Research Unit at the University of California, Davis, for analysis of plasma iron and zinc (by atomic absorption spectrophotometry; 20, 21), ferritin (by immunoradiometric assay; Diagnostic Products Co, Los Angeles), C-reactive protein (by rate nephelometry; Beckman Instruments Inc, Galway, Ireland), retinol (by HPLC; 22), transferrin (by rate nephelometry; Beckman Instruments Inc), and erythrocyte riboflavin (by HPLC; 23). Total iron-binding capacity (TIBC) was determined as transferrin concentration divided by 0.7 (24). Percentage transferrin saturation was calculated by dividing the plasma iron concentration by TIBC. All analyses (except plasma retinol and erythrocyte riboflavin) were performed in duplicate.
Morbidity data.
Infant morbidity data were collected by maternal recall monthly before 6 mo and weekly during the intervention phase (between 6 and 12 mo). To assist this process during the intervention phase, mothers were given a daily grid on which to record stool numbers, vomiting, and specific symptoms of fever and respiratory illness between visits. For data analysis, diarrhea was defined as
3 liquid or semiliquid stools in 24 h. Respiratory illness was defined as the presence of a purulent nasal discharge or cough. Morbidity prevalence, for example, diarrhea prevalence, was calculated as the ratio of the number of days diarrhea was present to the number of days information was collected on diarrhea for each child. Morbidity incidence, for example diarrhea incidence, was the ratio of the number of new episodes of diarrhea to the number of days at risk for an episode of diarrhea (excluding days with missing data or diarrhea already present). An episode was considered new when it was preceded by
2 symptom-free days.
Cross-sectional study
After completing the longitudinal study, preliminary data analysis indicated no significant differences in growth between the 4 intervention groups and less growth-faltering than had been observed in the 79 infants 612 mo of age in the cross-sectional study done earlier to estimate the required sample size. To confirm the latter observation, we decided to collect additional cross-sectional data (n = 385) on infants who received no intervention at all. The selection criteria for the longitudinal and cross-sectional study infants (both before and after the longitudinal study) were the same except that the age of infants at recruitment was 612 mo in the cross-sectional study compared with 1 mo in the longitudinal study. Information collected on the infants in the cross-sectional study included baseline data on their households, infant-feeding practices, and one-time measurement of weight, length, triceps skinfold thickness, and midupper arm and head circumferences with use of the same methods as described for the longitudinal study.
Statistical analysis
Data were entered by using EPI-INFO (version 6.03; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, World Health Organization, 1996), and analyses were done by using PC-SAS (release 6.04; SAS Institute Inc, Cary, NC). Analysis of variance was used to examine differences in baseline characteristics between the 4 intervention groups. Analysis of covariance was used to determine whether there were significant differences between the intervention groups in weight gain, length gain, or changes in hemoglobin concentration, hematocrit, percentage transferrin saturation, or plasma ferritin, zinc, or retinol concentration, or erythrocyte riboflavin from 6 to12 mo of age, with the independent variables being intervention group and values at 6 mo of age of the respective dependent variable. Baseline characteristics between the pooled intervention groups and the pooled cross-sectional study infants were compared by using t tests and chi-square tests. Growth status (weight-for-age and length-for-age) of the pooled intervention and pooled cross-sectional study infants was compared at each age (612 mo) by using Student's t tests. Differences in baseline characteristics and the potential influence of seasonality were controlled for by using multiple regression analysis.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
Breast-feeding frequency and the contribution of project complementary food to the mean daily energy intake from non-breast-milk foods are shown in Table 4
. Breast-feeding frequency was not significantly different between the 4 groups. At 12 mo of age, all but 2 infants were still being breast-fed. From age 7 to 12 mo, the project foods provided 5001096 kJ/d,
4078% of the total non-breast-milk food intake. At 7 mo, intake of energy from complementary foods was significantly higher in the WM group than in the WF group. No significant differences were observed between intervention groups at 8 and 12 mo of age. At 10 mo, the percentage of energy from complementary foods contributed by the project food was significantly higher in the WM group than in the KF group, but no differences were observed between the 4 groups in total energy intake from non-breast-milk foods. The contribution of project foods to iron, zinc, vitamin A, and riboflavin intake is shown in Table 5
. As expected, the intake of these micronutrients was significantly higher in the group fed the fortified product (WM). There were no significant differences in intake between the other 3 groups (W, WF, and KF) except at 7 mo, when intake of iron and zinc was higher in the KF group than in the W group, and intake of riboflavin was higher in the WF than in the W group. Generally, by 12 mo of age, when the intake of nonproject foods increased, the percentage contribution of project food to the total intake of these micronutrients decreased. However, for the WM group, even at 12 mo of age, the fortified food still contributed >75% of the total micronutrient intake from foods.
|
|
-1.2 at 12 mo of age (17). Similarly, length-for-age z scores did not differ significantly between the 4 intervention groups (Figure 2
-0.2 at 6 mo and -0.6 at 12 mo of age. These results were not altered when infant sex, energy intake from project foods, or the total energy intake from complementary foods were controlled for. Weight gain and length gain between 6 and 12 mo, and other anthropometric indexes (midupper arm and head circumferences, triceps and subscapular skinfold thicknesses, MAFA, and MAMA) also did not differ significantly between the 4 intervention groups (Table 6
|
|
|
|
|
|
The percentage of infants with values below the cutoffs for hemoglobin (<100 g/L), hematocrit (<0.33), percentage transferrin saturation (<16%), ferritin (<12 µg/L), zinc (<10.7 µmol/L), and retinol (<0.7 µmol/L) are given in Table 8
. The percentage of infants with low ferritin increased significantly (P < 0.05) between 6 and 12 mo of age (reaching 4857% at 12 mo) in groups W, WF, and KF, but not in group WM (10.7% at 12 mo). Similarly, the prevalence of low plasma retinol concentrations decreased significantly between 6 and 12 mo in group WM (P < 0.05) but not in the other 3 groups.
|
2% and was still not significantly different between the 4 groups.
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
50 per group is sufficient to detect a difference
0.5 kg in weight gain or 1.0 cm in length gain over the 6-mo period with a power of 0.9. As it turned out, the weight gain from 6 to 12 mo of age of the "control" group in the intervention (those fed unmodified Weanimix) was not as low as initially anticipated, and the maximum difference observed between this group and any of the other intervention groups was only 0.15 kg. A sample size of 539 per group would have been necessary to show statistical significance for a difference of that magnitude with a power of 0.9. There are several possible explanations for the growth results. First, all subjects in the intervention were given the project foods free of charge, which may have improved overall food availability for the infants. Second, all 4 intervention foods had a relatively high macronutrient content compared with traditional complementary foods typically fed to infants in West Africa (5, 7, 26). It would have been desirable for study purposes to include a group assigned to koko alone, but this was not considered acceptable because of the known nutritional limitations of koko. Third, the attention received by all intervention infants through regular weekly visits may have influenced the mothers' child-care and infant-feeding practices, and the regular morbidity surveillance may have prompted them to seek treatment earlier for their sick infants (27). Fourth, seasonal differences in the timing of data collection for the longitudinal compared with the cross-sectional studies could have confounded the results, even though this was controlled for during data analysis. However, this would most likely have worked against finding greater growth in the intervention infants because the proportion of infants who were 912 mo of age during the hungry season was greater in the intervention groups than in the cross-sectional group. Finally, the precautions taken to reduce contamination of project foods by providing vacuum flasks to all mothers in the intervention study may have reduced infant infection, which has been negatively associated with growth in other studies (2830). We showed, in a concurrent study carried out in this same community, that vacuum flask storage reduced microbial contamination of Weanimix (31). It is unknown whether this effect is large enough to reduce infant morbidity. In hindsight, the study design would have been stronger had we included in the randomized longitudinal study a fifth group that was not provided with any of the project foods, but for budgetary and practical reasons this was not considered feasible or acceptable to the community.
All of the above explanations may account for the improvement in growth of the intervention groups compared with the nonintervention group and the lack of significant differences in growth between intervention groups. Nonetheless, given that some (though not all) studies have reported positive growth effects of supplementation with micronutrients such as zinc (3235), iron (3638), and vitamin A (39, 40), it is surprising that there was no significant difference in growth between the group fed the micronutrient-fortified food and the other 3 groups. It is possible that the micronutrient needs of infants at this age have been overestimated and that the control food (unmodified Weanimix), along with frequent breast-feeding, was nutritionally adequate. However, the biochemical results from this study indicate otherwise, because the infants fed diets W, WF, and KF had lower iron and vitamin A status at 12 mo than the WM group. Therefore, the results suggest that either the micronutrient deficiencies in this population were not severe enough to impair growth, or the growth response to micronutrient supplementation was constrained by other factors such as frequent infections (28, 29) or prenatal programming (25).
Of the 3 alternatives to Weanimix examined (WM, WF, and KF), only the micronutrient-fortified food resulted in improved micronutrient status. In all groups except the WM group, hemoglobin concentration declined between 6 and 12 mo of age (although the mean values at 12 mo of age did not differ significantly between groups). Fortification with vitamins and minerals clearly prevented the depletion of iron stores in group WM. About 50% of infants in each of the other 3 groups (W, WF, and KF) had plasma ferritin concentrations <12 µg/L by 12 mo of age, whereas only 11% of infants in the WM group had concentrations below this cutoff. Despite the high iron content of fish powder, its addition to Weanimix and koko did not improve infant iron status.
There are several possible reasons for this. Diets with phytate-iron molar ratios
6 have poor iron bioavailability (41). However, only the unmodified Weanimix had a phytate-iron molar ratio greater than this (7.3 compared with 2.2, 4.0, and 4.7 for WM, WF, and KF, respectively). It is therefore unlikely that interference from phytate is the reason for the lack of benefit from fish powder. Alternatively, high rates of malaria in this population could be an important factor. Malaria parasitemia has been reported to be a common cause of anemia in this age group (4244). Besides the increased destruction of red blood cells, reduced iron absorption and disturbed iron metabolism during acute episodes (4547) may increase the requirement for iron above normal physiologic needs. Although the addition of fish powder almost doubled the iron content of the food compared with unmodified Weanimix, the amount of iron in WF and KF was still considerably lower than that in WM. The mean daily intake of 33 g WF, which had an iron content of 0.1 mg/g, provided only 3.3 mg Fe/d, which is lower than the estimated 10.8 mg/d required from complementary foods with medium iron bioavailability (4).
The change in plasma zinc concentration between 6 and 12 mo of age did not differ significantly between groups. The average zinc concentration at 6 mo was lower than values reported in some studies (48), but comparable with 6- and 12-mo values in several other studies (33, 49, 50). Some studies have reported improved linear growth in zinc-supplemented infants (32, 33, 51), especially in those who were stunted or had low plasma zinc concentrations at baseline (51). No such effects were observed in these study infants. The project foods contributed a large proportion of average daily zinc intake, but the total zinc intake from all complementary foods in the W, WF, and KF groups combined was still only
81% of the recommended amount (2.8 mg/d; 4), whereas the WM group consumed an average of 281% of the recommended intake. Despite this, at 6 and 12 mo of age only 5 and 8 infants, respectively, had low plasma zinc concentrations (<10.7 µmol/L). Therefore, it is likely that zinc status was generally satisfactory and that this accounts for the lack of response (in both plasma zinc and growth) to increased zinc intake by the WM group. However, we cannot rule out the possibility that the zinc added to the WM food was poorly absorbed.
Infants fed the vitamin and mineral fortified diet had a significant increase in plasma retinol between baseline and 12 mo, whereas no improvement was observed in the other 3 groups. At 6 mo of age, 29% of the study infants had plasma concentrations <0.7 µmol/L. By 12 mo of age, this declined significantly in the WM group but increased in the other 3 groups. Vitamin A deficiency in the Brong Ahafo region as a whole is common; a recent survey indicated that 42% of children from 6 mo to 5 y of age had serum retinol values <0.35 µmol/L and 11% of infants 611 mo of age had a modified relative dose response >0.06 (R Agble, Ministry of Health, unpublished data, 1998). In our study, the improvement in plasma retinol concentration in group WM could be attributed to the significantly higher intake of the vitamin by this group. Typically, complementary foods fed to infants in this population contain little vitamin A. Provitamin A carotenoids in foods such as palm soup, palm oil, pawpaw, mangoes, and dark-green leafy vegetables are the main sources of vitamin A in the adult diet, but are not usually fed to infants and young children. Breast milk is therefore an important source of vitamin A for infants. However, breast milk vitamin A concentrations could be low due to inadequate maternal dietary intake and poor nutritional status (52). In rural mothers in southern Ghana, the average breast milk retinol concentration was only 1.0 µmol/L (53), which is much lower than the value for well-nourished mothers (2.3 µmol/L; 54). Using the former value, we estimated that the total vitamin A intake (from breast milk and other foods) between 6 and 10 mo of age by infants in groups W, WF, and KF was only 5070% of the recommended 350 µg/d (55). By contrast, the WM group consumed 23 times the recommended intake as a result of fortification of the Weanimix. These results indicate that feeding W or WF to breast-fed infants in this population, in which maternal breast milk vitamin A concentration is likely to be low and other sources of vitamin A are infrequently offered before 12 mo of age, does not provide sufficient vitamin A. Fortification of complementary foods with vitamin A should be seriously considered in Ghana, especially given the reported beneficial effects of vitamin A supplementation on childhood mortality and severity of infections in children in the northern part of the country (56, 57).
It was surprising that there was no significant difference in erythrocyte riboflavin concentration between the 4 groups, given that infants fed WM had a significantly higher dietary intake of the vitamin than did the other 3 groups. During the 6-mo intervention period, the total daily intake of riboflavin from non-breast-milk foods in groups W, WF, and KF was much lower than the estimated 0.2 mg/d required from complementary foods for breast-fed infants (4). The results of our study differ from those of other studies in which riboflavin supplementation resulted in improved status in weaning-age infants in China and Gambia (58, 59). In our study, riboflavin status was determined by direct measurement of erythrocyte flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD), the coenzyme, using HPLC. Erythrocyte FAD is a good indicator of tissue stores and a measure of long-term riboflavin status (60). Measurement of erythrocyte FAD by HPLC has been used in other studies to assess riboflavin status of very-low-birth-weight infants (61) and healthy male adults (23). In healthy adult males, a mean FAD concentration of 280 ± 21 nmol/L was reported (23), which is similar to the average concentration in infants in our study. As far as we know, a cutoff indicating low tissue stores for infants has not been established. The lack of effect on riboflavin status in our study may be attributable to the relatively higher riboflavin stores at 6 mo in the Ghanaian infants compared with Gambian infants (
59), which may reflect differences in breast-milk riboflavin concentrations. In the Gambian infants, riboflavin status was assessed by erythrocyte glutathione reductase activity coefficient (EGRAC). At 6 mo of age, EGRAC was
1.27 in the unsupplemented infants, which is considered equivalent to an erythrocyte FAD concentration of 196 nmol/L [calculated by using the equation of Becker and Wilkinson (62): erythrocyte FAD = 53 nmol/L ÷ (EGRAC - 1)]. The latter value is lower than the median erythrocyte FAD concentration in the infants in our study at 6 mo of age. It should be noted, however, that predicting red blood cell riboflavin concentration from EGRAC values may be problematic because different versions of the assays may have different normal ranges.
Morbidity was not significantly different between the 4 intervention groups. The incidence rates of diarrhea, fever, and respiratory illness were similar to rates reported for rural Guatemalan infants (51), whereas the prevalence of fever was higher in infants in our study, probably due to the prevalence of malaria in the region. The prevalence rates of all 3 types of illness were similar to rates typically observed in infants 611 mo of age in our study region (14). The lack of effect of micronutrient fortification on morbidity differs from the results of some studies in which supplementation with iron, zinc, or vitamin A did reduce morbidity (6365). Inadequate statistical power may account for this. For example, to detect a 30% decrease in diarrheal morbidity with a power of 0.8, we would have needed a sample size of 200 per group. On the other hand, not all studies have shown an effect of micronutrient supplementation on morbidity (6668), and it is possible that micronutrient malnutrition in these Ghanaian infants was not severe enough to affect those outcomes.
We conclude that feeding improved complementary foods to Ghanaian infants between 6 and 12 mo of age most likely improved growth compared with the usual growth pattern of infants in the community. The addition of fish powder to dehydrated koko supported growth just as well as did Weanimix. Efforts to improve complementary feeding in developing countries have often focused on the use of cheap, locally available ingredients as a way to make these foods affordable to poor families. Although these measures may improve the macronutrient content of the diet, the micronutrient quality is often neglected. Our results indicate that fortification of Weanimix with vitamins and minerals improves iron stores and vitamin A status. Whether local foods can achieve the same results is not clear. Fortification with some nutrients such as iron and vitamin A may be the most effective strategy.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
K. H. Paul, K. L. Dickin, N. S. Ali, E. C. Monterrosa, and R. J. Stoltzfus Soy- and Rice-Based Processed Complementary Food Increases Nutrient Intakes in Infants and Is Equally Acceptable with or without Added Milk Powder J. Nutr., October 1, 2008; 138(10): 1963 - 1968. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||