|
|
||||||||
Original Research Communications |
1 From the Departments of Nutrition and Epidemiology, Harvard School of Public Health, Boston, and the Channing Laboratory and the Division of Preventive Medicine, Department of Medicine, Brigham and Women's Hospital and Harvard Medical School, Boston.
See corresponding editorial on page 951.
2 Supported by research grants HL24074, HL34594, CA40356, and DK 46200 and nutrition training grant T32DK07703 from the National Institutes of Health.
3 Address reprint requests to FB Hu, Department of Nutrition, Harvard School of Public Health, 665 Huntington Avenue, Boston, MA 02115. E-mail: Frank.hu{at}channing.harvard.edu.
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Objective: The objective was to examine the associations between intakes of individual saturated fatty acids and their food sources in relation to the risk of coronary heart disease (CHD).
Design: This was a prospective cohort study of 80082 women in the Nurses' Health Study aged 3459 y. Subjects had no known cardiovascular disease, cancer, hypercholesterolemia, or diabetes, and completed validated food-frequency questionnaires in 1980.
Results: During 14 y of follow-up, we documented 939 incident cases of major CHD events. In multivariate analyses in which age, smoking, and other covariates were controlled for, intakes of short- to medium-chain saturated fatty acids (4:010:0) were not significantly associated with the risk of CHD. In contrast, intakes of longer-chain saturated fatty acids (12:018:0) were each separately associated with a small increase in risk. The multivariate RR for a 1% energy increase from stearic acid was 1.19 (95% CI: 1.02, 1.37). The ratio of polyunsaturated to saturated fat was strongly and inversely associated with CHD risk (multivariate RR for a comparison of the highest with the lowest deciles: 0.58; 95% CI: 0.41, 0.83; P for trend < 0.0001). Conversely, higher ratios of red meat to poultry and fish consumption and of high-fat to low-fat dairy consumption were associated with significantly greater risk.
Conclusion: A distinction between stearic acid and other saturated fats does not appear to be important in dietary advice to reduce CHD risk, in part because of the high correlation between stearic acid and other saturated fatty acids in typical diets.
Key Words: Coronary heart disease women saturated fat foods dietary fat Nurses' Health Study stearic acid
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The differential effects of specific saturated fats on plasma lipids and lipoproteins imply that these fats may have different effects on the risk of CHD. So far, epidemiologic studies have assessed only the association of the risk of CHD with total saturated fatty acids; to our knowledge, no data are available regarding the associations between individual saturated fatty acids and the risk of CHD. Recently, we reported a modest positive association between saturated fat intake and the risk of CHD in women participating in the Nurses' Health Study (9). The present analysis examines in detail the relations of intake of specific saturated fatty acids and their major food sources with the incidence of CHD during 14 y of follow-up.
| SUBJECTS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In 1980, a 61-item food-frequency questionnaire was included to assess intakes of specific fats and other nutrients. In 1984, the food-frequency questionnaire was expanded to include 116 food items. Similar questionnaires were used to update dietary intakes in 1986 and 1990. The primary change in the revised questionnaire was the creation of individual questions about groups of nutritionally similar food items that had been collapsed into single items on the more compressed original questionnaire. The reproducibility and validity of the food-frequency questionnaires were described in detail elsewhere (11, 12). In validation studies among subsamples of the main study, correlation coefficients between energy-adjusted saturated fat intakes derived from the 61-item and 116-item food-frequency questionnaires and from multiple, 1-wk dietary records (after within-person variation in the diet records was accounted for) were 0.65 and 0.68, respectively (L Sampson, E Rimm, M Stampfer, B Rosner, W Willett, unpublished observations, 1997).
To calculate intakes of specific saturated fatty acids and other nutrients, a commonly used unit or portion size for each food (eg, one egg or one slice of bread) was specified and the participant was asked how often on average during the previous year she had consumed that amount. Nine responses were possible, ranging from "never" to "
6 times/d." Nutrient intakes were computed by multiplying the frequency of consumption of each unit of food by the nutrient content of the specified portions. Composition values for individual saturated fatty acids and other nutrients were obtained from US Department of Agriculture sources (13).
After up to 4 mailings, 98462 women returned the 1980 dietary questionnaire. We excluded those who left
10 items blank, those with implausibly low or high scores for total food or energy intake [ie, <2094 kJ (500 kcal) or >14650 kJ (3500 kcal)/d], and those with previously diagnosed cancer, angina, myocardial infarction, stroke, or other cardiovascular diseases. Women reporting high serum cholesterol concentrations or diabetes were excluded because these disorders are associated with a risk of CHD and also could have caused the women to change their diets. The final 1980 baseline population consisted of 80082 women.
Ascertainment of endpoint
The primary endpoint for this study was nonfatal myocardial infarction or fatal coronary disease occurring after the return of the 1980 questionnaire but before 1 June 1994. We sought to review medical records for all such reports. Records were reviewed by study physicians with no knowledge of the subjects' self-reported risk factor status. Myocardial infarction was confirmed by using World Health Organization criteria: symptoms plus either diagnostic electrocardiographic changes or elevated cardiac enzymes (14). Infarctions that required hospital admission and for which confirmatory information was obtained by interview or letter, but for which no medical records were available, were designated as probable (17%). We included all confirmed and probable cases in our analyses because results were the same after probable cases were excluded.
Deaths were identified from state vital records and the National Death Index or were reported by next of kin or the postal system; follow-up for deaths was >98% complete (15). Fatal coronary disease was defined as fatal myocardial infarction if this was confirmed by hospital records or autopsy, or if coronary disease was listed as the cause of death on the death certificate and there was evidence of previous coronary disease. CHD cases were designated as presumed if the underlying cause on the death certificate was CHD but no records were available; these cases constituted
14.7% of fatal CHD cases. Analyses limited to confirmed cases yielded similar results, although with less precision. We also included sudden death within 1 h of the onset of symptoms in women with no other plausible cause of death (other than coronary disease); these cases constituted
12.3% of fatal CHD cases.
Data analysis
Person-years (the number of persons studied times the number of years of follow-up) for each participant were calculated from the date of return of the 1980 questionnaire to the date of the first CHD event, death, or 1 June 1994, whichever came first. Women were divided into quintiles according to the percentage of energy from each type of saturated fatty acid. Incidence rates were calculated by dividing the number of events by person-years of follow-up in each quintile. The relative risk (RR) was computed as the rate in a specific category of fat intake divided by that in the lowest quintile, with adjustment by 5-y age categories. In multivariate models using pooled logistic regression (16), we simultaneously included intakes of total energy, dietary cholesterol, protein, and fiber, and percentages of energy from saturated fat, monounsaturated fat, polyunsaturated fat, and trans fat, in addition to other potential confounding variables. In such models, the coefficient for a specific type of fat can be interpreted as an estimate of the effect of that fat compared with the same energy from carbohydrates (17). For analyses of food consumption in relation to the risk of CHD, we calculated composite scores for red meat, poultry and fish, low-fat dairy products, and high-fat dairy products and classified women into quintiles of these scores; median values for each quintile were used to test for a linear trend.
Because intakes of individual saturated fatty acids were highly correlated because of shared food sources, we did not enter all the specific saturated fatty acids into the model simultaneously. To distinguish 18:0 from other long-chain saturates, we entered the intake of 18:0 and the sum of 12:0, 14:0, and 16:0 into the model simultaneously. Because of a high correlation between 18:0 and 16:0 as a result of shared food sources, we also calculated 18:0 intakes, adjusted for 16:0 and other saturates, using the regression method that has been described for energy adjustment (17). We then conducted analyses using adjusted 18:0 intakes.
To reduce within-subject variation and best represent long-term dietary intakes, we used repeated measures of diet in the analyses (9). In particular, the incidence of CHD was related to the cumulative average of individual saturated fatty acids from all available questionnaires up to the start of each 2-y follow-up interval in a pooled logistic model. Because changes in diet after the development of intermediate endpoints such as angina, hypercholesterolemia, and diabetes may confound the diet-disease associations (18), we stopped updating the diet at the beginning of the time interval during which individuals developed those intermediate endpoints. Most covariates were updated biennially, including age (5-y category), time period (7 periods), body mass index (5 categories), cigarette smoking (never, past, and current smoking of 114, 1524, and
25 cigarettes/d), menopausal status (premenopausal, postmenopausal without hormone replacement, postmenopausal with past hormone replacement, and postmenopausal with current hormone replacement), parental history of myocardial infarction before age 60 y, multivitamin use, vitamin E supplement use, and alcohol consumption (0, 04, 514, and
15 g/d). Aspirin use (none, 16/wk,
7/wk, and dose unknown) was assessed in 1980, 1982, 1984, and 1988 and regular vigorous exercise was assessed in 1980.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
55% of total saturated fatty acid intakes and 18:0 accounted for
16%. The primary contributors to 16:0 and 18:0 intakes in our cohort included beef as a main dish, cheese, beef as a sandwich or mixed dish, and hamburgers (Table 2
|
|
|
|
|
|
We also examined the association between the ratio of polyunsaturated fat (which itself was strongly inversely related to risk) to saturated fat (ie, the sum of 12:018:0) and the risk of CHD (Table 5
). After adjustment for age, smoking, other nondietary variables, and intakes of monounsaturated fat, trans fat, protein, and total energy, a higher ratio was associated with a significantly lower risk of CHD (RR: 0.79; 0.70, 0.89) for each 0.2-unit increment in the ratio. When the ratio was treated as a categorical variable (Figure 1
), the multivariate RRs across deciles of the ratio (the median values ranged from 0.23 to 0.72 from the lowest to the highest deciles) were 1.0 (reference), 0.92, 0.90, 0.87, 0.94, 0.81, 0.68, 0.72, 0.58, and 0.58 (0.41, 0.83).
|
Because beef and dairy products were the main sources of saturated fatty acids, we examined the associations between intakes of red meat (beef, pork, or lamb as a main dish; beef as a sandwich or mixed dish; hamburger; hot dog; processed meat; and bacon) and high-fat dairy products (whole milk, hard or cream cheese, ice cream, and butter) and the risk of CHD (Table 7
). For the purpose of comparison, we also analyzed the associations between intakes of poultry and fish and low-fat dairy products (skim or low-fat milk, yogurt, and cottage cheese) and the risk of CHD. After adjustment for age, consumption of red meat and high-fat dairy products was associated with an increased risk of CHD, whereas consumption of poultry and fish and low-fat dairy products was associated with a lower risk. These associations were substantially attenuated in multivariate analyses and became nonsignificant, but the direction of the associations remained unchanged. The ratio of red meat to poultry and fish consumption was more strongly associated with the risk. Similarly, the ratio of high-fat to low-fat diary product consumption was positively associated with the risk of CHD. Among the dairy products, whole-milk consumption was associated with a significantly increased risk of CHD. The multivariate RRs across categories of intake of whole milk [almost never, <244 g/wk (1 glass/wk), 4881464 g/wk (26 glasses/wk), 244 g/d (1 glass/d), and
488 g/d (2 glasses/d)] were 1.0, 1.20, 1.17, 1.48, and 1.67 (1.14, 1.90; P for trend < 0.0001). In contrast, a greater consumption of skim milk was associated with a nonsignificantly lower risk of CHD; corresponding RRs across categories of intake were 1.0, 0.83, 0.77, 0.89, and 0.78 (0.63, 0.96; P for trend = 0.09).
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Because all individual long-chain saturated fatty acids (12:0, 14:0, 16:0, and 18:0) were associated with a small increase in risk, collectively, these fatty acids were associated with a modest increased risk, an effect that was distinct from that of the short- to medium-chain fatty acids. We did not find evidence that the relation between 18:0 and risk of CHD was weaker than the associations of other saturated fats with CHD risk. However, our ability to distinguish among the types of saturated fats was limited by their high intercorrelations because their predominant sources were the same foods. This not only creates a high degree of statistical collinearity, but also suggests that distinguishing among specific types of saturated fat may not be of practical importance in dietary advice. Nevertheless, because of collinearity, our study could not address the effect of the addition of substantial amounts of purified 18:0 to the diet.
Most metabolic studies have shown that medium-chain saturated fatty acids with 810 carbons do not raise plasma cholesterol concentrations (19), although a recent study suggested the opposite (20). On the other hand, 12:0, 14:0, and 16:0 do increase total, LDL-, and HDL-cholesterol concentrations (7). Yu et al (19) reviewed 15 metabolic studies and found that 14:0 was more hypercholesterolemic than were the other fatty acids. More recent studies, however, showed no increase in total or LDL cholesterol when 14:0 was substituted for 16:0 (21), but did show an increase in HDL cholesterol when 14:0 was substituted for 16:0 or 18:1 (22).
Although 18:0 has little effect on total and LDL-cholesterol concentrations compared with carbohydrate, it may lower HDL cholesterol compared with monounsaturated or polyunsaturated fatty acids, and the HDL-lowering effect of 18:0 was particularly strong among women (19). Aro et al (6) reported recently that compared with a diet rich in dairy fat (rich in 14:0 and 16:0), 18:0 reduced LDL concentrations but also reduced HDL concentrations. Thus, the ratios of LDL to HDL and of apolipoprotein B to apolipoprotein A-I were not affected significantly. In addition, 18:0 increased Lp(a) concentrations (6) and may activate factor VII (23) and impair fibrinolysis (24). Overall, evidence from recent metabolic studies, similar to our data, does not appear to support making a distinction between 18:0 and other saturated fatty acids when giving dietary advice for reducing CHD risk. In addition to the well-known effects on CHD risk of LDL cholesterol, the overall adverse effects of long-chain saturated fatty acids on CHD risk observed in this study may be in part related to postprandial responses to these fatty acids. Weintraub et al (25) found that postprandial triacylglycerol concentrations were highest for a diet rich in saturated fat, lowest for a diet rich in n-3 polyunsaturated fat, and intermediate for a diet rich in n-6 polyunsaturated fat.
The observed relation between saturated fatty acid intake and risk of CHD was much weaker than that predicted by international comparisons (2). A major problem with the international comparisons was serious confounding by lifestyle variables such as physical activity and obesity and other aspects of diet such as fiber intake. Our results are consistent with the possibility that the proportional increase in plasma HDL-cholesterol concentration produced by saturated fatty acids somewhat compensates for its adverse effect on LDL-cholesterol concentrations. Finally, we found a strong inverse association between the ratio of polyunsaturated to saturated fat and the risk of CHD. This result is consistent with findings from dietary intervention trials in which substitution of polyunsaturated for saturated fat without a reduction in the total fat content of the diet substantially reduced the risk of CHD (26, 27).
In conclusion, a distinction between 18:0 and other saturated fats in dietary advice to reduce CHD risk does not appear to be important, in part because of the high correlation between 18:0 and other saturated fats in typical diets. However, these data do suggest that replacement of long-chain saturated fat with polyunsaturated fat is likely to reduce substantially the risk of CHD. Our results also support recommendations to substitute poultry and fish and low-fat dairy products for red meat and high-fat dairy products to reduce the risk of CHD.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-6 and
-3 series reduce postprandial lipoprotein levels. Chronic and acute effects of fat saturation on postprandial lipoprotein metabolism. J Clin Invest 1988;82:188493.
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
H. Soyeurt, P. Dardenne, F. Dehareng, C. Bastin, and N. Gengler Genetic Parameters of Saturated and Monounsaturated Fatty Acid Content and the Ratio of Saturated to Unsaturated Fatty Acids in Bovine Milk J Dairy Sci, September 1, 2008; 91(9): 3611 - 3626. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
W. K Al-Delaimy Commentary: Lactose and ischaemic heart disease: a weak 28-year-old hypothesis Int. J. Epidemiol., August 24, 2008; (2008) dyn170v1. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
H. Soyeurt, F. Dehareng, P. Mayeres, C. Bertozzi, and N. Gengler Variation of {Delta}9-Desaturase Activity in Dairy Cattle J Dairy Sci, August 1, 2008; 91(8): 3211 - 3224. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. Elwood, A. Fehily, J. Pickering, and I. Givens Pentadecanoic acid (15:0), milk, and ischemic heart disease Am. J. Clinical Nutrition, May 1, 2008; 87(5): 1540 - 1541. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
Q. Sun and F. B Hu Reply to P Elwood et al Am. J. Clinical Nutrition, May 1, 2008; 87(5): 1541 - 1541. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. E. Croissant, S. P. Washburn, L. L. Dean, and M. A. Drake Chemical Properties and Consumer Perception of Fluid Milk from Conventional and Pasture-Based Production Systems J Dairy Sci, November 1, 2007; 90(11): 4942 - 4953. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
Q. Sun, J. Ma, H. Campos, and F. B Hu Plasma and erythrocyte biomarkers of dairy fat intake and risk of ischemic heart disease Am. J. Clinical Nutrition, October 1, 2007; 86(4): 929 - 937. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
H. Soyeurt, A. Gillon, S. Vanderick, P. Mayeres, C. Bertozzi, and N. Gengler Estimation of Heritability and Genetic Correlations for the Major Fatty Acids in Bovine Milk J Dairy Sci, September 1, 2007; 90(9): 4435 - 4442. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. B. Ebbeling, M. N. Pearson, G. Sorensen, R. A. Levine, J. R. Hebert, J. A. Salkeld, and K. E. Peterson Conceptualization and Development of a Theory-Based Healthful Eating and Physical Activity Intervention for Postpartum Women Who Are Low Income Health Promot Pract, January 1, 2007; 8(1): 50 - 59. [Abstract] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
L. Qi, R. M. van Dam, K. Rexrode, and F. B. Hu Heme Iron From Diet as a Risk Factor for Coronary Heart Disease in Women With Type 2 Diabetes Diabetes Care, January 1, 2007; 30(1): 101 - 106. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
H. Soyeurt, P. Dardenne, A. Gillon, C. Croquet, S. Vanderick, P. Mayeres, C. Bertozzi, and N. Gengler Variation in Fatty Acid Contents of Milk and Milk Fat Within and Across Breeds J Dairy Sci, December 1, 2006; 89(12): 4858 - 4865. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
D. Mozaffarian and E. B. Rimm Fish intake, contaminants, and human health: evaluating the risks and the benefits. JAMA, October 18, 2006; 296(15): 1885 - 1899. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
L. Dauchet, P. Amouyel, S. Hercberg, and J. Dallongeville Fruit and Vegetable Consumption and Risk of Coronary Heart Disease: A Meta-Analysis of Cohort Studies J. Nutr., October 1, 2006; 136(10): 2588 - 2593. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
H. Soyeurt, P. Dardenne, F. Dehareng, G. Lognay, D. Veselko, M. Marlier, C. Bertozzi, P. Mayeres, and N. Gengler Estimating Fatty Acid content in cow milk using mid-infrared spectrometry. J Dairy Sci, September 1, 2006; 89(9): 3690 - 3695. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. C Larsson, L. Bergkvist, and A. Wolk High-fat dairy food and conjugated linoleic acid intakes in relation to colorectal cancer incidence in the Swedish Mammography Cohort Am. J. Clinical Nutrition, October 1, 2005; 82(4): 894 - 900. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. L. Fernandez and K. L. West Mechanisms by which Dietary Fatty Acids Modulate Plasma Lipids1 J. Nutr., September 1, 2005; 135(9): 2075 - 2078. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
W. Zhu and E. J. Smart Myristic Acid Stimulates Endothelial Nitric-oxide Synthase in a CD36- and an AMP Kinase-dependent Manner J. Biol. Chem., August 19, 2005; 280(33): 29543 - 29550. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
W. A Zatonski and W. Willett Changes in dietary fat and declining coronary heart disease in Poland: population based study BMJ, July 23, 2005; 331(7510): 187 - 188. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
F. B Hu Protein, body weight, and cardiovascular health Am. J. Clinical Nutrition, July 1, 2005; 82(1): 242S - 247S. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. J Nestel, K. Baghurst, D. M Colquhoun, R J. Simes, K. Mehalski, H. D White, A. M Tonkin, A. Kirby, C. Pollicino, and for the Long-Term Intervention with Pravastatin in Relation of diet to cardiovascular disease risk factors in subjects with cardiovascular disease in Australia and New Zealand: analysis of the Long-Term Intervention with Pravastatin in Ischaemic Disease trial Am. J. Clinical Nutrition, June 1, 2005; 81(6): 1322 - 1329. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Ishinaga, A. Ueda, T. Mochizuki, S. Sugiyama, and T. Kobayashi Cholesterol Intake Is Associated with Lecithin Intake in Japanese People J. Nutr., June 1, 2005; 135(6): 1451 - 1455. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
H. K. Choi, W. C. Willett, M. J. Stampfer, E. Rimm, and F. B. Hu Dairy Consumption and Risk of Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus in Men: A Prospective Study Arch Intern Med, May 9, 2005; 165(9): 997 - 1003. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
L. E. Kelemen, L. H. Kushi, D. R. Jacobs Jr., and J. R. Cerhan Associations of Dietary Protein with Disease and Mortality in a Prospective Study of Postmenopausal Women Am. J. Epidemiol., February 1, 2005; 161(3): 239 - 249. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. K. Roberts and R. J. Barnard Effects of exercise and diet on chronic disease J Appl Physiol, January 1, 2005; 98(1): 3 - 30. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
E. W. Gregg, B. L. Cadwell, Y. J. Cheng, C. C. Cowie, D. E. Williams, L. Geiss, M. M. Engelgau, and F. Vinicor Trends in the Prevalence and Ratio of Diagnosed to Undiagnosed Diabetes According to Obesity Levels in the U.S. Diabetes Care, December 1, 2004; 27(12): 2806 - 2812. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. Yoo, T. Nicklas, T. Baranowski, I. F Zakeri, S.-J. Yang, S. R Srinivasan, and G. S Berenson Comparison of dietary intakes associated with metabolic syndrome risk factors in young adults: the Bogalusa Heart Study Am. J. Clinical Nutrition, October 1, 2004; 80(4): 841 - 848. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
K. Hoffmann, B.-C. Zyriax, H. Boeing, and E. Windler A dietary pattern derived to explain biomarker variation is strongly associated with the risk of coronary artery disease Am. J. Clinical Nutrition, September 1, 2004; 80(3): 633 - 640. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. L McCullough and W. C Willett Reply to JE Lincoln Am. J. Clinical Nutrition, August 1, 2003; 78(2): 349 - 350. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
W. K Al-Delaimy, E. Rimm, W. C Willett, M. J Stampfer, and F. B Hu |