|
|
||||||||
Original Research Communication |
1 From the Strategic Discovery Research & Development (VAM, CAS, NKE and SJD) and Clinical Biostatistics Operations (PPR), Ross Products Division, Abbott Laboratories, Columbus, OH.
2 Reprints not available. Address correspondence to VA Mustad, Ross Products Division, Abbott Laboratories 105670-RP3-2, 625 Cleveland Avenue, Columbus, OH 43215-1724. E-mail:vikkie.mustad{at}abbott.com.
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Objective: The objective was to study the relative effect of tocotrienol supplements of different compositions (mixed
- plus
-, high
-, or P25-complex tocotrienol) on blood lipids, fasting blood glucose, and the excretion of 8-iso-prostaglandin F2
, a measure of oxidative stress, in healthy hypercholesterolemic men and women.
Design: This was a double-blind, randomized, parallel-design study in which subjects (n = 67 men and women) consumed 1 of 3 commercially available tocotrienol supplements or a safflower oil placebo for 28 d. Blood and urine samples were obtained before and after the 28-d supplementation phase for analysis of fasting blood lipids, glucose, tocotrienols and tocopherols, and 8-iso-prostaglandin F2
.
Results: Overall, serum tocotrienols were increased in subjects who consumed tocotrienols, which showed that the putatively active components were absorbed. No significant differences in mean lipid or glucose concentrations were observed among the 4 treatment groups at the end of the 28-d supplementation phase. However, when the values were expressed as a percentage change from the concentrations during the presupplementation run-in phase, LDL cholesterol increased slightly (7 ± 2%) but significantly (P < 0.05) in the group consuming the mixed
- plus
-tocotrienol supplement when compared with LDL cholesterol in the group consuming the P25-complex tocotrienol. Neither mean concentrations nor the percentage change in 8-iso-prostaglandin F2
differed significantly among treatments.
Conclusion: Supplementation with 200 mg tocotrienols/d from 3 commercially available sources has no beneficial effect on key cardiovascular disease risk factors in highly compliant adults with elevated blood lipid concentrations.
Key Words: Tocotrienols total cholesterol LDL cholesterol fasting blood glucose urinary 8-iso-prostaglandin F2
cardiovascular disease
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A widely studied group of functional cholesterol-lowering compounds are the tocotrienols. Tocotrienols are members of the vitamin E family of compounds, and the various isomers (ie,
,
,
, and ß) are isolated from natural oils such as those from palm, rice bran, or barley. Like tocopherols, tocotrienols have antioxidant properties in vitro (3). Studies have shown that, unlike tocopherols, tocotrienols can inhibit cholesterologenesis and lower blood LDL cholesterol (412). Studies in humans showed that the consumption of 130220 mg/d of mixed or purified tocotrienols by persons with hypercholesterolemia can result in reductions in LDL cholesterol of 821% within 46 wk. These effects have been shown in addition to the dietary effects on lipid lowering in subjects consuming a low-fat National Cholesterol Education Program (NCEP) Step I diet (10, 11). These studies have also reported significant reductions in fasting glucose, serum platelet factor 4, and thromboxane ß2, and these reductions suggest that tocotrienols can provide multiple cardiovascular health benefits.
However, inconsistent effects of tocotrienols also have been reported in the literature. Results from other well-controlled studies showed no benefits of tocotrienols provided as palm oil concentrates (1315) or tocotrienyl acetate (16) in patients with hypercholesterolemia after supplementation with 160240 mg/d for up to18 mo. Although there also were slight differences between the populations and designs of these studies and those of previous studies showing positive results, it is possible that the composition of the supplements used may have contributed to the negative results observed. For example, data from in vitro studies indicate that
- and
-tocotrienols are more potent than
-tocotrienol in suppressing the reductase activity of 3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaryl coenzyme A (4, 5). Most recently, a novel tocotrienol [didesmethyl (P25) tocotrienol] isolated from rice bran oil was reported to have potent effects on lowering cholesterol (6, 10).
Tocotrienols may provide a natural and effective nutritional adjunct to diet therapy for reducing the risk of CVD. However, because of uncertainty surrounding the most effective tocotrienol composition for reducing LDL cholesterol, the present study was initiated to assess the relative effectiveness and potency of commercially available tocotrienol concentrates of different compositions. A secondary objective was the assessment of the effects of these tocotrienols on other key factors related to CVD risk, including fasting blood glucose concentrations and 8-iso-prostaglandin F2
(8-iso-PGF2
), which is an in vivo marker of oxidative stress.
| SUBJECTS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
4.52 mmol/L. Subjects were considered healthy on the basis of blood chemistry analysis and as they reported on a medical history questionnaire. Subjects were excluded from the study if they currently (or within the previous 3 mo) were taking prescription medication known to have an effect on blood lipids, including but not limited to 3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaryl coenzyme A reductase inhibitors, fibric acid derivatives, thiazide diuretics and ß-blockers (for hypertension), and steroid-based medications (topical or oral), as reported by the subjects on a medical history questionnaire. Women taking oral contraceptives or hormone replacement therapy before the study were admitted, provided they had been following the same regimen (ie, dosage) for
3 mo, and they were required to maintain that regimen for the duration of the study. In addition, subjects were excluded from the study if they were currently (within the past 30 d) taking bulk laxatives or dietary supplements to reduce blood cholesterol concentrations [including but not limited to garlic, phytosterol-based margarines, soy protein (>20 g/d), red yeast rice, and soluble psyllium fiber (>5 g/d)] as reported by subjects on the medical history questionnaire. The protocol was approved by the Institutional Review Board of Ross Products Division, and written informed consent was obtained from the subjects.
Study design
The study followed a randomized, double-blind, parallel design. All subjects were instructed to consume an American Heart AssociationNCEP Step I diet for the entire 7-wk study, beginning 21 d before supplementation (the run-in phase); in the supplementation phase, subjects were randomly assigned (according to their baseline LDL-cholesterol concentrations) to receive 1 of 3 tocotrienol supplements or placebo for 28 d. Subjects agreed to follow a meal pattern including a regular daily lunch meal during the study period, and they were instructed to consume all capsules at the midday meal; this was done to enhance subject compliance and facilitate disintegration of the capsule and absorption of the lipid-soluble tocotrienols. Supplements were plainly labeled with the appropriate treatment number to ensure maintenance of the double-blind status of the study.
A trained and licensed phlebotomist performed venipuncture to obtain fasting blood samples (
20 mL) from subjects once at screening, on days 19 and 21 during the Step I diet run-in phase, and on days 47 and 49 during the supplementation phase. Blood samples were analyzed for total cholesterol, LDL cholesterol, triacylglycerols, HDL cholesterol, glucose (all samples), and tocotrienols and tocopherols (run-in and supplementation phases only), and a chemistry panel that included liver enzymes, kidney, and thyroid profile was performed on screening and final supplementation phase blood samples only. Urine samples [overnight (12 h) plus morning void] were collected by subjects twice, on day 19 or 21 during the Step I diet run-in phase and on day 47 or 49 during the supplementation phase, for analysis of 8-iso-PGF2
and creatinine.
Subjects were instructed to maintain their habitual physical activity and lifestyle throughout the study, and body weight was monitored at each study visit. Subjects were asked to refrain from taking drugs or dietary supplements known to affect blood lipids, as well as supplemental vitamin E or other antioxidants, during the course of the study. Case report forms were filled out every other week, and subjects maintained daily diaries for recording supplement intake and any study deviations or adverse events during the 28-d supplementation phase.
Study supplements
During the supplementation phase, participants assigned to the placebo group received capsules containing 1 g safflower oil (Solgar Laboratories, Leonia, NJ). Participants assigned to the 3 tocotrienol groups received gelatin capsules containing either a mixed
- plus
-tocotrienol extract from palm oil (Tocovid; Hovid Sdn Bhd, Ipoh, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia), a high
-tocotrienol extract from rice bran oil (Nutriene; Yasoo Health, San Diego), or a novel P25-complex extract from rice bran oil (EvolvE; Bionutrics, Phoenix, AZ). The composition of these supplements is shown in Table 1
. The total daily intake of tocotrienols was 200 mg; however, because of the inherent differences in the composition and processing of the supplements and because capsules from different manufacturers were of different doses, the number of capsules consumed differed among the treatments. Subjects were advised that they could observe differences between treatments on the basis of the number, size, and color of the supplement capsules; however, they remained completely blinded to the identity of the treatment groups throughout the study. Study supplements were repackaged, and bottles were sealed and labeled with a masked study number. Daily
-tocopherol intake was <1, 62, 92, and 88 mg, respectively, from the placebo, the mixed
- plus
-tocotrienol extract, the high
-tocotrienol extract from rice bran oil, and the P25-complex tocotrienol supplements (Table 1
).
|
Tocotrienols and tocopherols in serum and in the study supplements were assayed by Craft Technologies, Inc (Wilson, NC). Briefly,
1-mL samples of blood and study supplements were extracted with hexane, dried under nitrogen gas, and resuspended in 200 µL hexane. Tocotrienols and tocopherols were analyzed by normal-phase HPLC with the use of a Diol column (LiChrosorb; Merck KgaA, Darmstadt, Germany) and hexane:dioxane (95:5) as the mobile phase (18). The retention time of individual peaks was compared with that of pure tocotrienols and tocopherols. By this method, the recovery of tocotrienols spiked into human serum was >90%, and the calibration curves were linear from 0.2 to 20 µmol/L.
Urine collection and analysis
Urine [overnight (12 h) plus first morning void] was collected in 1000-mL polyethylene bottles. Bottles were kept cold during the collection period in insulated bags containing freezer packs. Immediately after the return of the bottles, aliquots (10 and 50 mL) of each urine sample were sampled and stored at -70°C before analysis of 8-iso-PGF2
and creatinine. The 8-iso-PGF2
was measured by radioimmunoassay of urine samples after alkaline hydrolysis (GenOx Corp, Baltimore). The average CV for this assay was 6.2%. Urinary creatinine was determined by a validated automated colorimetric assay on a diagnostic autoanalyzer (Spectrum EPx; Abbott Laboratories). Values are expressed as pmol 8-iso-PGF2
/mmol creatinine.
Step I diet modification and assessment
All subjects received dietary instruction for lowering blood cholesterol according to the NCEP (1) Step I diet guidelines that restricted total fat intake to
30% of energy, saturated fat to
10% of energy, and cholesterol to
300 mg/d. Instruction included a 1-h group education session during which subjects 1) received verbal instruction from a registered, licensed dietitian; 2) watched a 15-min video entitled "Heart-Healthy Eating" (Patient Information Video Series; Dallas: American Medical Communications, 1994); and 3) received diet guides, recipes, and booklets (eg, Step by Step, NIH publication #94-2920; Bethesda, MD: National Institutes of Health, 1994) incorporating and supporting these guidelines. Subjects were instructed on how to complete a food-frequency questionnaire [MEDFICTS (meat, eggs, dairy, fried foods, in-baked goods, convenience foods, table fats, and snacks); from Step by Step], which was designed to assess adherence to NCEP Step I and Step II (in which total and saturated fat and dietary cholesterol are further restricted) diets (1). The frequency of intake and portion sizes of common foods that are major contributors of fat, saturated fat, and cholesterol were recorded; a numerical value was assigned on the basis of the frequency of consumption and the serving sizes of foods within each category; and a total score was calculated. The total achievable score was 190 points; a score
70 indicated the need to make some dietary changes, a score of 4070 indicated compliance with a Step I diet, and a score of <40 indicated compliance with a Step II diet. Targets for dietary change could be identified within each category, and subjects not complying with Step I diet recommendations were counseled about specific dietary changes. Additional diet questionnaires were completed by subjects throughout the 7-wk study for assessment of diet compliance as described below.
Compliance
Case-report forms were completed biweekly to ensure compliance with study instructions. To be considered in compliance with the supplementation regimen, subjects were required to consume
90% of the capsules, as assessed by capsule counts and the maintenance of daily diaries. Subjects completed diet questionnaires between days 5 and 10 of the diet run-in (mid-run-in phase), again between days 18 and 21 during the run-in phase, and finally between days 24 and 28 during the supplementation phase. In addition, all 5 fasting blood samples, all 2 urine samples, and all paperwork (including diaries and diet assessment questionnaire) had to be returned to the study monitor and verified for a subject to be considered compliant with the study protocol.
Statistical and analytic plans
It was calculated that a sample size of 17/group was needed to detect a 10% change in total cholesterol of 0.52 mmol/L with a two-sided test at
= 0.05 and statistical power of 80%. The eligible subjects were ranked in descending order, blocked by 4, and randomly assigned to 4 groups according to their baseline LDL-cholesterol concentrations. The data collected at baseline and during the run-in phase (average from study days 17 and 21) and the supplementation phase (average from study days 47 and 49) were examined to test the assumption of normally distributed residuals with the use of the Shapiro-Wilk test. Comparison of the groups for values obtained during the run-in and supplementation phases and the calculated percentage change from the run-in phase to the supplementation phase was first carried out with two-way repeated-measures analysis of variance (ANOVA). Because an interaction (group-by-time) was significant, one-way ANOVA was used to analyze the run-in and supplementation phases and the percentage change data, if the assumption of nonnormally distributed residuals was met at each time point. Those variables for which the residuals showed evidence of being nonnormally distributed (with P < 0.05 used for the Shapiro-Wilk test) at
1 time point were ranked, and one-way ANOVA was carried out on the rank data (Kruskal-Wallis one-way layout test). When significant group effects were detected, a post hoc Tukeys honestly significant difference test was used to identify the pair that caused the significant difference. In addition, Spearmans rank correlation coefficients were calculated to compare blood lipid and tocotrienol data and the correlation between blood lipid and urine data. Demographic variables were summarized with frequencies and percentages. All results were considered to be significant if P was <0.05.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
Overall, the concentrations of tocotrienols were higher in the serum of subjects consuming the active tocotrienol supplements than in the serum of those who did not (Figure 1
), which indicates that the putatively active components were absorbed. The groups consuming the mixed
- plus
-tocotrienol and P25-complex tocotrienol supplements had 2027% higher serum concentrations of
-tocotrienol than did the placebo group, whereas the group consuming the high
-tocotrienol supplement had a 9-fold elevation in the plasma concentrations of this isomer. However, because of the large variability in the serum concentrations of tocotrienols detected, only serum concentrations of
-tocotrienol were significantly higher than those in the placebo group (P < 0.05). Tocotrienol supplements also contained
-tocopherol that was 2550% higher in all active supplement groups than in the placebo group (P < 0.05; Figure 1
). Differences were also observed among groups in
-tocopherol concentrations (lower in the
-tocotrienol group than in the placebo group, P < 0.05) and ß-tocopherol (higher in both rice bran oil tocotrienol groups than in the placebo group, P < 0.05).
|
- plus
-tocotrienol supplement than those in the group consuming the P25-complex tocotrienol supplement. With the exception of a small positive correlation between the serum concentration of ß-tocotrienol and total cholesterol concentrations at the end of the supplementation phase (r = 0.260, P < 0.049), no significant correlations were observed between the serum tocotrienol concentrations and changes in fasting serum lipids or glucose (data not shown).
|
after tocotrienol supplementation, expressed per mmol urinary creatinine or as a percentage change from the run-in phase (Table 4
(data not shown). | DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
These results were unexpected, given that our study design, subject population, and dosage and composition of tocotrienols were nearly identical to those in 3 double-blind, placebocontrolled studies by Qureshi et al (1012) that showed substantial cholesterol reduction. In contrast, the results from the current study did not show any blood cholesterol- or glucose-lowering response, even in those subjects who had the highest serum concentrations of tocotrienols and, thus, greater absorption. Our study data are confirmatory, however, of those from other controlled studies reporting no effects on blood lipids (1316). These studies used supplements in compositions or doses similar to those in the studies described above but had slightly different populations and designs. For example, Mensink et al (14) conducted a study with men having serum total cholesterol between 6.46 /L and 7.98 mmol/L who were advised to maintain their typical diet while consuming 160 mg tocotrienols/d for 6 wk. Wahlqvist et al (16) reported no change in blood lipids in subjects who consumed from one 60-mg palm oil tocotrienol capsule/d to 4 such capsules, providing 240 mg/d, despite significant increases in serum total tocotrienols. In the study by Tomeo et al (13), subjects with coronary artery disease started at a dose of 160 mg tocotrienol/d, but the dosage was increased after 3 mo in an (unsuccessful) attempt to lower serum lipids. Despite the ineffectiveness of the tocotrienol supplements in this latter study, however, ultrasonography scans of the patients carotid arteries revealed apparent atherosclerotic lesion regression in 7 of the 25 patients taking the active supplement, whereas none of the control group exhibited such regression and 10 of the 25 patients showed carotid artery lesion progression. Consequently, the authors concluded that the antioxidant properties of the supplements were beneficial in this patient population, despite having no measurable effects on blood lipids.
Although tocotrienols have been shown to be antioxidants in vitro, the results of this current study showed no effects on the excretion of 8-iso-PGF2
. Isoprostanes are formed as products of noncyclooxygenase oxidative modification of arachidonic acid that results from free radical attack of cell membrane phospholipids or circulating LDLs (19, 20). They are released in response to cellular activation, they circulate in plasma, and they are excreted in the urine; thus, their formation has been described as a noninvasive marker of oxidation and is therefore of potential relevance to human vascular disease (2123). Furthermore, elevated excretion has been shown to be "normalized" to within "healthy" ranges after supplementation with high concentrations of antioxidants, primarily
-tocopherol (24). It is possible that effects on other measures of oxidation (eg, LDL oxidation) that were not assessed in this study could have been observed (16).
We also considered that a tocotrienol intake >200 mg/d might be needed for a significant effect on the endpoints of interest. We chose to study an intake of 200 mg/d, which represented the midrange of the concentrations of total tocotrienol supplementation reported in the literature and accordingly was a level at which we strongly expected to find significant cholesterol-lowering effects, if there were any. The fact that we observed significant elevations in the serum concentrations of tocotrienol with no cholesterol-lowering trends in those subjects who had the highest serum tocotrienol concentrations suggests that the amount of supplementation was not a limiting factor. Furthermore, subjects were instructed to consume all capsules at the midday meal instead of throughout the day as was the protocol in most other studies. Although this was primarily done to enhance subject compliance with a multiple-capsule supplementation scheme, we felt that it should also have facilitated the absorption of the lipid-soluble tocotrienols and the maintenance of adequate plasma concentrations throughout the study. A recent study in healthy adult volunteers confirms that the absorption of mixed tocotrienols is greater when they are given with a meal than when they are given to subjects in a fasted state (25). Although concentrations of tocotrienols were increased after the 28-d supplementation phase, especially after administration of the
-tocotrienol-rich supplement, overall plasma concentrations of tocotrienols were lower than those of vitamin E, as has been reported in other studies (14, 16, 26). Results from recent studies suggest that this may not be the result of impaired bioavailability of tocotrienols; instead, the maintenance of a low plasma concentration of tocotrienols after supplementation more likely reflects alternative (unknown) pathways of their metabolism and excretion (27).
In conclusion, the results of this study do not support a beneficial effect of commercially available tocotrienol supplements on CVD risk factors in men and women with hypercholesterolemia. Dietary methods with proven cholesterol-lowering benefits (eg, reducing saturated fat and cholesterol and adding soluble fiber and soy protein) should not be overlooked as the first-step dietary approach to reducing CVD risks.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-tocopherol attenuates the impact of gamma tocotrienol on hepatic 3-hydroxy-3-methyl glutaryl-coenzyme A reductase activity in chickens. J Nutr 1996;126:38994.
-Tocotrienol as a hypocholesterolemic and antioxidant agent in rats fed atherogenic diets. Lipids 1993;28:11138.[Medline]
is increased in hypercholesterolemia. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol 1997;17:32305.
- and
-Tocotrienols are metabolized to carboxyethyl-hydroxychroman derivatives and excreted in human urine. Lipids 2001;36:438.[Medline]This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
J. A. McAnally, J. Gupta, S. Sodhani, L. Bravo, and H. Mo Tocotrienols Potentiate Lovastatin-Mediated Growth Suppression In Vitro and In Vivo Experimental Biology and Medicine, April 1, 2007; 232(4): 523 - 531. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. Fairus, R. M Nor, H. M Cheng, and K. Sundram Postprandial metabolic fate of tocotrienol-rich vitamin E differs significantly from that of {alpha}-tocopherol. Am. J. Clinical Nutrition, October 1, 2006; 84(4): 835 - 842. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. Schaffer, W. E. Muller, and G. P. Eckert Tocotrienols: Constitutional Effects in Aging and Disease J. Nutr., February 1, 2005; 135(2): 151 - 154. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
B.-L. Lee, A.-L. New, and C.-N. Ong Simultaneous Determination of Tocotrienols, Tocopherols, Retinol, and Major Carotenoids in Human Plasma Clin. Chem., December 1, 2003; 49(12): 2056 - 2066. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |