|
|
||||||||
ORIGINAL RESEARCH COMMUNICATION |
1 From the Department of Human Nutrition, LMC Centre for Advanced Food Studies (LG-P, KB, and MH) and the Department of Mathematics and Physics (MJ), The Royal Veterinary and Agricultural University, Frederiksberg, Denmark, and the Department of Clinical Physiology and Nuclear Medicine, The National University Hospital, Copenhagen (LH)
2 Supported by The Danish Dairy Research Foundation and The Danish Food Technology Programme (FØTEK 3).
3 Address reprint requests to K Bukhave, Department of Human Nutrition, LMC Centre for Advanced Food Studies, The Royal Veterinary and Agricultural University, DK-1958 Frederiksberg C, Denmark. E-mail: klb{at}kvl.dk.
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Objective: We investigated the effect of 3 sources of calcium served with the 3 main meals on nonheme-iron absorption from a 4-d diet.
Design: 59Fe absorption was estimated from whole-body retention measurements in 14 women aged 2134 y, each of whom consumed four 4-d diets in a randomized crossover design. The diets differed in the source of calcium as follows: a basic diet (BD) with a low content of calcium (224 mg Ca/d), a BD with a glass of milk served at each meal (826 mg Ca/d), a BD with calcium lactate (802 mg Ca/d), and a BD with a milk mineral isolate containing calcium (801 mg Ca/d). The 2 latter calcium sources were added to selected foods of the BD (rye bread, white bread, chocolate cake, and orange juice), and these foods were consumed with the 3 meals. All diets provided 13.2 mg Fe/d.
Results: No significant differences in nonheme-iron absorption were found between the BD and the BD supplemented with milk, calcium lactate, or the milk mineral isolate [7.4% (95% CI: 5.3%, 10.5%), 5.2% (3.5%, 7.9%), 6.7% (5.0%, 8.9%), and 5.1% (3.2%, 7.9%), respectively; P = 0.34].
Conclusion: Consumption of a glass of milk with the 3 main meals or of an equivalent amount of calcium from fortified foods does not decrease nonheme-iron absorption from a 4-d diet.
Key Words: Nonheme-iron absorption calcium milk iron bioavailability radioisotopes 59Fe whole-body counting women Denmark
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Because numerous dietary factors influence iron absorption (7), the effect of calcium may not be as pronounced when calcium is served as part of a whole diet (8). Therefore, measurements of iron absorption from the whole diet over a longer period of time are warranted (9). Previous multiple-meal studies on the effect of calcium on nonheme-iron absorption have also shown inconsistent and conflicting results, partly because of differences in experimental design. When nonheme-iron absorption was measured for a 5-d period, a 30% higher absorption was found for dairy calcium served at breakfast and dinner than for dairy calcium distributed more equally throughout the day (10). In contrast, a 70% reduction in nonheme-iron absorption was observed in a 1-d study in which subjects consumed supplemental calcium carbonate with the 3 main meals (11). These results conflict with those obtained in a study by Reddy and Cook (12), in which no difference in nonheme-iron absorption between a low- and a high-calcium diet was found. The inhibitory effect of calcium on iron absorption has been reported to be dose related, with no effect at <40 mg Ca/meal and no further inhibitory effect at >300 mg Ca/meal (4). In addition to differences in calcium sources (ie, endogenous or supplemental) and in the iron status of the subjects investigated, this range for inhibition may, at least partly, explain the aforementioned discrepancies. Therefore, the aim of the present study was to compare the effect on nonheme-iron absorption of serving different sources of calcium with the 3 main meals with that of serving a basic diet (BD) with a low calcium content (ie, 6088 mg/meal) in young women with low iron stores who consumed 4 strictly controlled, 4-d whole diets.
| SUBJECTS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
± SD) with a mean weight of 65 ± 10 kg and a mean body mass index (in kg/m2) of 22.3 ± 2.6 participated in the study. One woman dropped out of the study before the beginning of the last period, ie, before her BD period. All the women were nonsmokers, and none of them were pregnant or lactating or took any vitamin or mineral supplements for
2 mo before or during the study. Ten subjects used oral contraceptives throughout the study, but none of the women routinely took any other medications. Blood donation was not allowed for
2 mo before or during the study. Twenty-nine subjects were screened 3 wk before the beginning of the study, and 14 subjects were selected for the study on the basis of relatively low iron stores, ie, a hemoglobin concentration
110 g/L and a serum ferritin concentration
40 µg/L. The participants were recruited from universities in the nearby area and received oral and written information about the study before they gave their written consent. The study was approved by the Research Ethical Committee of Copenhagen and Frederiksberg [(KF) 01-238/98] and the National Institute of Radiation Hygiene, Denmark.
Experimental design
The 4 diets in the study consisted of the BD, which was low in calcium, and the BD supplemented with 1 of the 3 following calcium sources: a glass of milk served at each main meal, calcium lactate (Merck 102102; Merck KGaA, Darmstadt, Germany), or a milk mineral isolate (MM) containing calcium (Arla Foods A/S, Aarhus, Denmark). The 2 latter calcium sources were added to selected foods of the BD: rye bread, white bread, chocolate cake, and orange juice. The content of calcium was evenly distributed between the meals (Table 1
). The study was double blinded with regard to the control diet and the 2 diets fortified with calcium lactate or MM. The study had a randomized crossover design with 4 periods, each of which lasted 18 d and featured strict control of dietary intake on days 14, when the subjects received the dietary intervention. The meals were extrinsically labeled with the radioisotope 59Fe, and the absorption of the isotope was measured by whole-body retention on day 17 of each period. Fasting blood samples were collected in the morning on day 18 of each period. The subjects were instructed to abstain from heavy physical exercise for 36 h, to not consume alcohol for 24 h, and to fast for 12 h before blood sampling and before the first meal in each intervention period. They were allowed to drink 0.5 L water provided by the Department of Human Nutrition, The Royal Veterinary and Agricultural University, Frederiksberg, Denmark, within the 12-h fasting period.
|
|
Isotopes and labeling procedures
The test meals, including bread, were thawed overnight before serving. The meals were extrinsically labeled
16 h before serving by pipetting the radioisotope solution (59FeCl3 in 0.1 mol HCl/L; Amersham Biosciences UK Limited, Buckinghamshire, United Kingdom) onto the bread served at each meal in amounts that gave exactly the same specific activity of 59Fe (0.80 kBq 59Fe/mg Fe) in all meals. The total dose in each period was 42 kBq 59Fe.
Milk mineral isolate
The MM used was produced from skim milk by acid precipitation of casein followed by ultrafiltration of the acidified whey, centrifugation (8500 x g for 30 s at 65°C), and spray drying. To ensure uniform composition of the MM, the isolate was supplied in batches of 5 kg taken from a pool. Each pool of MM was composed from 5 equal samples taken out of the production line.
Whole-body counting and calculation of nonheme-iron absorption
Whole-body retention of 59Fe was measured in a lead-lined steel chamber with 4 NE110 plastic scintillator blocks (Nuclear Enterprises Limited, Edinburgh) connected to conventional nuclear electronic modules and a multichannel analyzer system. The counting efficiency and energy window settings were established through measurements of water-filled phantoms whose outlines and weights are approximately equal to those of humans. The phantoms were filled with known concentrations of the isotope. In the actual setup and with the energy window used, the overall counting efficiency for 59Fe evenly distributed in a 77-kg phantom was
20%. To minimize contamination by atmospheric background activity, all subjects had a shower, washed their hair, and were dressed in hospital clothing before each measurement. The counting time was 10 min, and the results were corrected both for chamber background radiation and for the subjects own background radioisotope activity measured 1 wk before the beginning of the first intervention period. All radioactivity measurements were corrected for the physical decay of the isotope. Results are expressed as fractional absorption (percentage of ingested amount).
Dietary analyses
Duplicate portions of the 4 menus were freeze-dried, homogenized, and analyzed in duplicate for total iron, phytic acid, and calcium. The energy content was calculated with the use of a food-composition computer program (Danish Tables of Food Composition, DANKOST 2000, version 1.20; Danish Catering Center). Total iron and calcium were determined by atomic absorption spectrophotometry (Spectra-AA 200; Varian, Mulgrave, Australia) after wet-ashing in an MES 1000 Solvent Extraction system (CEM Corp, Matthews, NC) with 65% (by wt) suprapure nitric acid (Merck KgaA). The Standard Reference Material 1548a (typical diet; National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD) was used as the reference for iron [35.30 ± 3.77 µg/g (
± SD)] and calcium (1.97 ± 0.11 mg/g), and the analyzed values were 36.83 ± 4.04 µg/g (n = 6) and 1.90 ± 0.09 mg/g (n = 9), respectively. Phytic acid (inositol phosphates) analysis was performed by using high-performance ion chromatography as described previously (15), and results are given as the sum of inositol tri-, tetra-, penta-, and hexaphosphates.
Iron-status measurements
The blood samples taken on day 18 of each period were analyzed for hemoglobin and serum ferritin. After the subjects rested for 10 min in a supine position in the morning, blood samples were drawn with 20 G needles and minimal stasis from the cubital vein into evacuated EDTA-coated tubes and plain tubes (BD Vacutainer Systems; Becton Dickinson, Franklin Lakes, NJ). Hemoglobin was determined on a Sysmex analyzer (SysmexKX-21; Sysmex Corporation, Kobe, Japan). Serum ferritin analysis was performed by using a 2-site fluoroimmunometric assay with a Delfia fluorometer 1235 (PerkinElmer Life SciencesWallac Oy, Turku, Finland) and an AutoDELFIA Ferritin Kit (B069-101; PerkinElmer Life SciencesWallac Oy).
Expression of iron absorption
Iron absorption was expressed as unadjusted data and as data adjusted to a serum ferritin concentration of 40 µg/L (8). The adjusted data were calculated as follows:
![]() | (1) |
Statistical analyses
The sample size was calculated from our previous data on iron absorption from single meals containing similar amounts of meat and phytic acid (16). To obtain a power of 90%, 12 subjects are needed to detect a 1.5% change in iron absorption at a significance level of 0.05 (17). Serum ferritin and absorption data were converted to logarithms before statistical analyses, and the results were reconverted to antilogarithms. The logarithmic data were normally distributed, with variance homogeneity tested by plots and histograms of residuals. Shapiro-Wilks test for normal distribution was performed. Nonheme-iron absorption data are presented as means with 95% CIs. The effect of intervention type on nonheme-iron absorption and interactions between period and intervention type were analyzed by parametric two-way repeated-measures analysis of variance, followed by pairwise multiple comparisons with Tukeys honestly significant difference method. One-way analysis of variance was used to test for differences between absorption ratios and the effect of intake of phytic acid on nonheme-iron absorption. The difference between the mean absorption ratios and unity was tested in one-sample t tests. The data from the person who dropped out of the study before the last period are included in all the statistical analyses, except for the analyses of the absorption ratios. All statistical analyses were performed with the use of SPSS 11.0 for WINDOWS (SPSS Inc, Chicago).
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
: 15 µg/L; range: 644 µg/L) and hemoglobin concentrations (geometric
: 123 g/L; range: 115137 g/L). The subjects mean (± SD) energy intake was 10.7 ± 0.8 MJ/d. The mean calcium intake in the basic dietary period was 224 mg/d, and the intake was distributed as 6088 mg/meal. The mean calcium intakes in the milk, calcium lactate, and MM dietary periods were 826, 802, and 801 mg/d, respectively, and the distribution of intake was in the range of 253291 mg/meal (Table 3
|
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A dose-related inhibition of iron absorption by a low amount of calcium (40300 mg) was reported in a single-meal study, but no further inhibition was observed with calcium amounts >300 mg/meal (4). This dose-dependency of inhibition is further supported by a study in which no significant effect on iron absorption was observed by the addition of 172 mg Ca in the form of milk to a meal already containing 320 mg Ca (19). Thus, the absence of inhibitory effects on nonheme-iron absorption by calcium in some studies may be due to a high background amount of calcium. However, this was not the case in the present study, in which the amount of calcium in the BD was <90 mg/meal. The calcium-supplemented diets contributed 200 mg additional Ca to each meal. According to Hallberg et al (4), a 50% reduction in nonheme-iron absorption from the meals in the present study would have been expected, if the meals were served as single meals.
Phytic acid has been regarded as one of the most potent inhibitors of nonheme-iron absorption, and even small amounts of phytate can have a marked effect on nonheme-iron absorption. In 2 single-meal studies, 1836 mg phytic acid from bread reduced nonheme-iron absorption by
50%, and 88 mg phytic acid reduced absorption by 64% (20, 21). Analyses of phytic acid showed a significantly higher content in the fortified diets (calcium lactate and MM diets) than in the BD and the milk diet (Table 3
). Bread was the item responsible for the higher amounts of phytic acid (data not shown), which indicates that addition of calcium before leavening of the dough reduces the degradation of phytic acid during fermentation, in accordance with an earlier study in which the addition of 40 mg Ca to dough containing 80 g white-wheat flour nearly halved phytic acid degradation (4). Nevertheless, the higher amount of phytic acid in the 2 fortified diets did not have any effect on nonheme-iron absorption (P = 0.13). Furthermore, calculations of the inhibitory effect of phytic acid, as proposed by Hallberg et al (22), indicate a 6570% reduction in iron absorption with the amount of phytic acid in the meals in the BD and the BD plus milk and a 6772% reduction in iron absorption in the meals in the fortified diets. Thus, only a minor effect of the higher amount of phytic acid in the fortified diets is expected. In addition, it is possible that the rather high content of phytic acid in the meals in the BD (110194 mg/meal) may have been responsible for a strong inhibitory effect that could have masked a putative effect of calcium.
In addition to ascorbic acid, one of the commonly accepted enhancers of iron absorption is meat, and even small amounts of meat can have a significant effect. In a single-meal isotope study, nonheme-iron absorption increased by 44% with the addition of 50 g pork to a meal containing 220 mg phytic acid (16). In another single-meal study, the addition of 50 g beef to a bread meal with a phytic acid content of 88 mg had no effect on nonheme-iron absorption (21), whereas absorption increased by 86% with the addition of 50 g beef when the phytic acid content was raised to 882 mg. This suggests that the effect of meat is more pronounced in the presence of high amounts of phytic acid. Fish has also been shown to increase nonheme-iron absorption (a 12% increase with 40 g fish) (23). In the present study, meat in the form of beef, pork, turkey, and tuna fish was served at the 3 main meals in amounts ranging from 20 g at breakfast to 4075 g at lunch and 100 g at dinner, ie, in amounts representative of a Western diet. Thus, it is likely that these amounts may have increased nonheme-iron absorption from the calcium-supplemented diets.
It has been shown that single-meal studies may overestimate the effect of enhancers and inhibitors on iron absorption from the diet. Comparison of single meals and whole diets performed by serving the same meal once or 3 times/d showed 80% higher iron absorption from the single meal (24). Cook et al (8) compared the effect of whole diets designed to maximally inhibit or enhance nonheme-iron absorption with the effect of representative single meals and found a greater inhibitory and enhancing effect from single meals than from whole diets. The reasons for the lack of effect of calcium on nonheme-iron absorption when measured from a whole diet rather than from a single meal are unknown. The length of the period of fasting may be one explanation because it has been shown to affect intestinal iron absorption (25). Another possibility is that during whole-diet experiments, residual food in the intestine may moderate the effect of inhibitors and enhancers present in single parts of the diet.
The long-term effect of calcium supplementation on iron status has been assessed in only a few studies. In premenopausal women, no effect on serum ferritin was observed after the intake of 1000 mg CaCO3/d for 312 mo (26-28). These observations are in agreement with the results of cross-sectional studies showing no effect of dietary calcium on iron status (29, 30) but are in disagreement with the results of other cross-sectional studies showing lower serum ferritin concentrations in groups with a high intake of calcium from dairy products than in groups with a lower intake (31, 32). However, the effect of dietary calcium on iron status is small, ie, only a 1.6% decrease in serum ferritin concentration for every 100-mg/d increase in calcium intake (31).
A feasible approach for increasing calcium intake in persons who do not consume dairy products is calcium fortification of food products. However, little is known about the effect of such foods on nonheme-iron absorption. In the present study, 2 types of calcium were used for fortification: calcium lactate and an MM with a high content of calcium. Neither of these fortified diets had any negative effect on nonheme-iron absorption.
In conclusion, in the present study, quantities of calcium that corresponded to the recommended amounts in the Nordic Nutrient Recommendations and were served with the 3 main meals as milk or fortified foods for a 4-d period did not decrease overall nonheme-iron absorption. However, differences in methods and age groups in these types of studies warrant further investigations on the effect of calcium fortification on nonheme-iron absorption.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
The outline of the study was planned by MH. LG-P did most of the detailed planning, conducted the absorption studies, did statistical treatment of the data, prepared the first draft of the manuscript, and interpreted the results in collaboration with MH and KB. MJ estimated the whole-body retention of isotopes, calculated the radioactive doses, and described the method of whole-body measurements. LH was the clinician responsible for the radioisotope studies. All contributors were involved in preparation of the final draft of the manuscript. None of the authors had any conflicts of interest in relation to the study.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
M. B. Reddy, R. F. Hurrell, and J. D. Cook Meat Consumption in a Varied Diet Marginally Influences Nonheme Iron Absorption in Normal Individuals J. Nutr., March 1, 2006; 136(3): 576 - 581. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
Z. K Roughead, C. A Zito, and J. R Hunt Inhibitory effects of dietary calcium on the initial uptake and subsequent retention of heme and nonheme iron in humans: comparisons using an intestinal lavage method Am. J. Clinical Nutrition, September 1, 2005; 82(3): 589 - 597. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. Molgaard, P. Kaestel, and K. F Michaelsen Long-term calcium supplementation does not affect the iron status of 12-14-y-old girls Am. J. Clinical Nutrition, July 1, 2005; 82(1): 98 - 102. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |