|
|
||||||||
ORIGINAL RESEARCH COMMUNICATION |
1 From the Medical Research Council Epidemiology Resource Centre (SMR, SFB, HES, AAS, EMD, HJM, and CC) and the Developmental Origins of Adult Health and Disease Centre (DJPB), University of Southampton, Southampton, United Kingdom
2 Supported by the Medical Research Council, United Kingdom.
3 Reprints not available. Address correspondence to SM Robinson, MRC Epidemiology Resource Centre, University of Southampton, Southampton General Hospital, Southampton SO16 6YD, United Kingdom. E-mail: smr{at}mrc.soton.ac.uk.
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Objective: The aim was to examine the relation between fat intake and serum cholesterol concentrations in men and women whose birth weights were known.
Design: We studied a cohort of men and women aged 5971 y. Diet was assessed with a food-frequency questionnaire. Total, HDL-, and LDL-cholesterol concentrations and the ratio of HDL to LDL cholesterol were measured in fasting blood samples from 574 men and 562 women who did not have coronary heart disease.
Results: Total and saturated fat intakes were not associated with serum cholesterol concentrations in men or women. However, subdivision by birth weight showed associations in men but not in women. High intakes of total and saturated fat were associated with reduced HDL-cholesterol concentrations in men with birth weights
3.2 kg (7 lb) but not in men with higher birth weights. Similar effects on the HDL-to-LDL cholesterol ratio were observed (P for interaction = 0.02 for total fat and 0.01 for saturated fat). When 32 men taking cholesterol-lowering medication were excluded, the interactions were strengthened (P = 0.008 and 0.006, respectively).
Conclusion: The adverse effects of high intakes of total and saturated fat on serum cholesterol concentrations in men may be confined to those with lower birth weights.
Key Words: Cholesterol fat intake birth weight individual variability
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Epidemiologic studies have shown that persons with low birth weights are at an increased risk of coronary heart disease in adult life (4-9). This observation may be explained, in part, by an association between low birth weight and altered cholesterol metabolism. Disturbed intrauterine growth is associated with immediate changes in cholesterol concentrations, and follow-up studies have shown that serum cholesterol concentrations track from the age of 6 mo into adult life (10). One mechanism that may explain the link between prenatal growth and adult disease is a permanent change in gene expression in response to the early environment (11); it is possible that the variability in individual cholesterol responses to manipulation of dietary fat could originate through changes in gene expression that occurred during early development when growth was restricted. Persons with low birth weights may thus respond to high fat intakes in ways that make them more vulnerable to coronary heart disease.
Direct experimental evidence supports this hypothesis (12). In guinea pigs, modest restriction of the maternal diet during pregnancy led to an altered response in the adult offspring to a high cholesterol diet. In male offspring whose mothers' diets were restricted during pregnancy, high cholesterol feeding for a 6-wk period led to higher plasma total cholesterol concentrations than were found in male offspring whose mothers had been given unlimited food. When the offspring were divided into those with birth weights above or below the median, plasma total cholesterol concentrations before cholesterol feeding did not differ in the 2 groups. After cholesterol feeding, however, the concentrations were 31% higher in the group with lower birth weights. No similar effects were observed in the female offspring. This led to the conclusion that maternal undernutrition and altered prenatal growth permanently change cholesterol homeostasis in males. To investigate whether these effects are evident in humans, we examined the association between intakes of total and saturated fat and serum cholesterol concentrations in a cohort of 574 men and 562 women whose birth weights were recorded.
| SUBJECTS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Coronary heart disease was defined as the presence of
1 of the following: angina, as defined by the Rose-World Health Organization chest pain questionnaire (14); electrocardiography Minnesota codes 11, 12 (Q and QS codes) (15); or a history of surgery for coronary revascularization, either coronary artery bypass graft or coronary angioplasty. One hundred fourteen men and 77 women had coronary heart disease and were excluded from the analysis, which left 623 men and 598 women for the analysis. The study was approved by the East Hertfordshire Local Research Ethics Committee. All subjects gave written informed consent.
Dietary assessment
Diet was assessed by using an administered food-frequency questionnaire (FFQ) that was based on the European Prospective Investigation of Cancer questionnaire (16). The FFQ included 129 foods and food groups and was used to assess the average frequency of consumption of the listed foods over the 3-mo period before the home interview. The frequencies of other foods that were not listed on the FFQ were also recorded if consumed
1 time/wk. Standard portion sizes were allocated to each food (17) apart from milk and sugar for which daily quantities consumed were recorded. For all spreading fats and cooking oils used, individual brand names were collected so that the profiles of saturated, monounsaturated and polyunsaturated fat in these products could be estimated. Nutrient intakes were calculated by multiplying the frequency of consumption of a portion of each food by its nutrient content (18). Dietary interviews took place between 1998 and 2002.
Serum cholesterol measurements
Serum total cholesterol and HDL cholesterol were measured with standard enzymatic methods (19-21). LDL-cholesterol concentrations were derived with the Friedewald-Fredrickson formula (22). Fasting serum HDL- and LDL-cholesterol concentrations were available for 574 of the men and 562 of the women who attended clinic and who had no coronary heart disease.
Statistical analysis
Variables were summarized with the use of means and SDs or frequencies and proportions, as appropriate. Multiple linear regression was used to explore the main and interactive effects of birth weight and dietary fat intakes on cholesterol concentrations. Sex-specific SD scores for birth weight and each dietary characteristic were used as predictor variables in the regression models.
The distributions of total and saturated fat intakes, body mass index [BMI; calculated as weight (in kg)/height2 (in m)], HDL cholesterol, and the ratio of HDL to LDL cholesterol were positively skewed and were loge transformed for statistical analysis. Accordingly, the means and SDs for these variables are geometric. Analyses were based on continuously distributed variables throughout; sex-specific thirds of birth weights and adult fat intakes are used in the tables. Analyses were conducted with the STATA statistical software package version 8 (Stata Corp, College Station, TX).
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
3.2 kg (7 lb), higher intakes of total and saturated fat were associated with lower HDL-cholesterol concentrations. In men in the highest third of birth weight, ie, >3.65 kg (8 lb), these trends were reversed (P for interaction = 0.02 for total fat and 0.03 for saturated fat intakes, and P = 0.09 and 0.08, respectively, after adjustment for the effects of BMI, age, and alcohol intake). This interaction was not seen in the women (Table 3
|
Serum LDL-cholesterol concentrations in the men and women are shown in Table 4
according to birth weight and total and saturated fat intakes. Unlike the effects on HDL-cholesterol concentration, there were no clear differences in the association between total or saturated fat intake and LDL-cholesterol concentration in men or women of different birth weights. No interactive effects of birth weight and fat intake on serum total cholesterol concentrations were observed in either men or women (data not shown).
|
3.2 kg (7lb)], higher intakes of total and saturated fat were associated with lower HDL-to-LDL cholesterol ratios. In the men with birth weights in the highest third [ie, >3.65 kg (8lb)], these trends were reversed (P for interaction = 0.02 for total fat and 0.01 for saturated fat; adjusted P = 0.05 and 0.02, respectively).
|
3.2 kg (7lb), although the test for interaction was not significant. Exclusion of 42 women who were taking cholesterol-lowering medication from the analysis did not show significant interactions between fat intake and birth weight on any of the cholesterol outcomes considered (data not shown).
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Study population
The men and women we studied came from a large cohort of men and women who were born between 1931 and 1939 in the county of Hertfordshire, United Kingdom (13). At that time, the birth weights of all babies born in the county were recorded. The criteria for selection for the present study were that the men and women were living in the Eastern part of the county and were willing to take part in the study. Fifty-four percent of the men and women approached agreed to be interviewed at home, and their birth weights were comparable with those of the men and women who chose not to participate in the study. The energy intakes of the subjects were consistent with the requirements of older adults (23), although compared with the last national cohort of older men and women studied in 19941995, the percentage energy contributed by total and saturated fat was lower (24). In contrast with early ecological studies, but similar to other cross-sectional surveys, we did not find simple univariate associations between dietary fat intake and serum cholesterol concentrations (25-27). We assessed diet using an administered FFQ. Although there is concern that FFQs are prone to measurement error (28), random misclassification of a person's fat intakes would result in an attenuation of associations, and it is very unlikely that measurement error could explain the interactive effects of diet and birth weight on serum cholesterol concentration we observed.
Prenatal growth and adult cholesterol metabolism
Although associations between weight at birth and adult serum cholesterol concentrations have been described before, they are not consistent across studies (29, 30). For example, our finding of a positive association between birth weight and serum HDL-cholesterol concentration in men, after adjustment for current BMI, agrees with other reports (29); however, in the present study, we did not find this association in the women or with LDL- or total cholesterol concentrations in men or women. It has been suggested that part of the heterogeneity in the relation between birth weight and adult cholesterol concentrations is due to stronger associations reported in smaller studies and in studies of cholesterol concentrations in infants (30). Greater insight into the relation between prenatal growth and adult cholesterol metabolism may come from examination of proportions rather than size at birth. In a study conducted in adults in Sheffield, United Kingdom, whose abdominal circumference at birth had been recorded, small circumference predicted raised total and LDL-cholesterol concentrations (31). Associations with other measures of body size at birth, including birth weight, were weak. Because abdominal circumference at birth reflects liver size, and the liver has a major role in the regulation of cholesterol homeostasis (32), an inference is that impaired liver growth in utero resets cholesterol homeostasis toward a more atherogenic profile. In the study conducted in guinea pigs, adult liver weight tended to be reduced in the low-birth-weight offspring and was associated with a lower plasma HDL-cholesterol concentration and higher LDL-cholesterol concentration after cholesterol feeding in the males but not females (12).
Interactive influences on adult cholesterol metabolism
Our data suggest that adult cholesterol responses to dietary fat are conditional on birth weight, and hence prenatal growth, in men. This agrees with the experimental findings from the study conducted in guinea pigs, in which the cholesterol response to a cholesterol challenge was increased in low-birth-weight male offspring (12). This interactive effect of birth weight and postnatal diet on adult cholesterol concentrations was only evident after the challenge of a high-cholesterol diet, because basal cholesterol concentrations were similar in low- and high-birth-weight offspring. If combined effects of prenatal growth and postnatal diet influence adult cholesterol metabolism, this would suggest that the most atherogenic adult cholesterol profiles in men would be found in populations where restricted prenatal growth is common and where adult diets are high in total and saturated fatclearly of concern for populations in nutrition transition (33).
Effects of different types of dietary fat
We found no significant differences of the interaction between total or saturated fat intakes and birth weight on serum cholesterol concentrations, although we expected to see stronger effects with saturated fat intakes. One explanation may be that our ability to estimate saturated and unsaturated fat intakes separately was limited. Although we obtained brand information for all spreading fats and cooking oils used by the men and women studied, these products only account for
20% of the saturated fat intakes of older UK adults (24). Equal contributions to saturated fat intakes are made by cereal products and meat products, but we may not have had sufficiently detailed composition information to allow an accurate assessment of the separate fat fractions. For this reason, we did not include monounsaturated or polyunsaturated fat intakes in our analyses. We did not assess trans-fat intakes because our composition database was incomplete.
Sex differences in adult cholesterol metabolism
The interactive effects of prenatal growth and adult diet on serum cholesterol concentration were only seen in the men. Although our study may have insufficient statistical power to detect 3-way interactive effects of birth weight, fat intake, and sex on serum cholesterol concentrations, the finding agrees with a growing body of observational and experimental evidence of sex differences in the relation between prenatal growth and adult cholesterol concentrations. In a follow-up study conducted in Filipino adolescents whose mothers had been studied during pregnancy, low maternal energy status was associated with more atherogenic lipid profiles in the male adolescents than in the female adolescents, as indicated by LDL-, HDL-, and total cholesterol concentrations (34). These associations were independent of the adolescents' energy and fat intakes and their adiposity. Because in the female offspring, higher maternal energy status was associated with more atherogenic profiles, the authors suggested that there were sex differences in the relation between fetal nutrition and postnatal lipid metabolism. Such sex differences in cholesterol metabolism may be expected, because men and women also differ in their cholesterol response to a reduction in fat intake (35).
Combined effects of early and later experience on adult disease
Other studies have established that responses to adverse influences in adult life are conditioned by prenatal growth. In the American Nurses' Health Study, the highest risk of coronary heart disease was found in women who had low birth weight and high BMI as adults (36). In men from Helsinki, Finland, low income was associated with increased rates of coronary heart disease, as would be expected (37). The association, however, was confined to men who were thin at birth, which was defined by a low ponderal index (birth weight/length3). These findings are consistent with the ideas of Dubos (38), who wrote that "the effects of the physical and social environments cannot be understood without knowledge of individual history." The present study suggests that responses to dietary fat are also conditioned by prenatal growth, which could help to explain the inconsistent associations observed between birth weight and serum cholesterol concentration (29, 30) and in the cross-sectional relations between dietary fat intake and serum cholesterol concentration (25-27). The analysis of the effects of dietary fat on serum cholesterol concentrations therefore needs to take birth weight into account; conversely, the analysis of the effects of birth weight on serum cholesterol concentrations has to take current diet into account. If replicated, our findings could have implications for public health. Lower birth weight would define a group of men who are at increased risk of coronary heart disease and who may benefit from a reduction in their dietary fat intake.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
EMD, AAS, HES, DJPB, and CC designed the study. The study was supervised by EMD, AAS, HES, HJM, and the Hertfordshire Cohort Study Group. SMR and SFB were responsible for the dietary data. The data were analyzed by HES. All authors contributed to interpretation of the data. SMR and DJPB wrote the manuscript. None of the authors had a conflict of interest.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
E. Kajantie, D. J P Barker, C. Osmond, T. Forsen, and J. G Eriksson Growth before 2 years of age and serum lipids 60 years later: The Helsinki Birth Cohort Study Int. J. Epidemiol., April 1, 2008; 37(2): 280 - 289. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |