|
|
||||||||
ORIGINAL RESEARCH COMMUNICATION |
1 From the Department of Internal Medicine, Cardioangiology, and Hepatology, University Hospital S Orsola-Malpighi, Bologna, Italy (GR, PF, FMa, and FMo); the Department of Experimental Pathology, University of Bologna, Italy (MC and FL); the District Health Unit of Lugo, Local Health Unit of Ravenna, Ravenna, Italy (MB); and the Department of Medicine, McMaster University, Hamilton, Canada (CP)
2 Supported by a Basic Oriented Research grant from the University of Bologna.
3 Address reprint requests to G Ravaglia, Department of Internal Medicine, Cardioangiology, and Hepatology, University Hospital S Orsola-Malpighi, Via Massarenti, 9, 40138 Bologna, Italy. E-mail: ravaglia{at}med.unibo.it.
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Objective: We investigated in an elderly population whether 1) APOE4 is associated with hyperhomocysteinemia [plasma total homocysteine (tHcy) > 15 µmol/L], 2) hyperhomocysteinemia affects the association between APOE4 and high CRP (serum CRP > 3 mg/L), and 3) B vitamin status affects these associations.
Design: APOE4 genotypes were assessed and tHcy, CRP, and serum concentrations of folate and vitamin B-12 were measured in 671 cognitively healthy subjects (52% women; mean age: 73 y) from an Italian populationbased prospective cohort study.
Results: APOE4 carriers without high CRP [multivariate-adjusted odds ratio (OR): 0.22; 95% CI: 0.08, 0.59] had a lower risk of hyperhomocysteinemia than did noncarriers. The risk of high CRP was lower in APOE4 carriers without hyperhomocysteinemia (multivariate-adjusted OR: 0.51; 95% CI: 0.31, 0.85) than in noncarriers. The associations were not affected by B vitamin status.
Conclusion: Independently from B vitamin status, APOE4 carriers have a lower risk of hyperhomocysteinemia and of high CRP than do noncarriers, but the presence of one condition attenuates the association of APOE4 with the other condition.
Key Words: Homocysteine C-reactive protein apolipoprotein E elderly lipid metabolism
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Elevated blood concentrations of the sulfur amino acid homocysteine are another emerging risk factor for dementia (13, 14) and a predictor of vascular risk (15). Moderate hyperhomocysteinemia is common in elderly people and is usually caused by poor B vitamin status and reduced renal function (16, 17). An important fraction of plasma total homocysteine (tHcy) circulates bound to lipoproteins, particularly to VLDL (1820), but the possible association of APOE4 with homocysteinemia has, to our knowledge, never been thoroughly investigated. In this study, we used data from an elderly Italian cohort 1) to verify the hypothesis that APOE4 is associated with lower plasma concentrations of tHcy, 2) to investigate whether hyperhomocysteinemia affects the known association between circulating CRP and APOE4, and 3) to assess the effects of vitamin B status on these associations.
| SUBJECTS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
65 y residing in the Italian municipality of Conselice (the Emilia-Romagna region of Italy) participated in the prevalence study. Participants were screened with the Italian version of the Mini Mental State Examination (MMSE; 23), and participants scoring <24 underwent further examination with the Mental Deterioration Battery (24). Dementia was diagnosed without further neuropsychological evaluation for participants with MMSE scores <10. Standardized information on the general functional and mental status of these subjects was also obtained from a collateral informant (a relative or other person with reliable knowledge of the subject, such as the subject's physician). Dementia was defined with the use of clinical criteria from the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th edition (25). The same protocol was used to collect data on cognitive status at follow-up examination (in 20032004) for 676 persons who were free of dementia at baseline. For the other 124 persons who were free of dementia at baseline and who survived but declined to participate at follow-up or died before reexamination, information from multiple sources (the subjects themselves, relatives, general practitioners, and death certificates) was used to define the presence or absence of dementia.
Subjects were considered eligible for the present study only if they had a baseline MMSE score
24 and had not developed dementia by the time of follow-up, because all the main outcome measures are risk factors for this condition and the resulting confounding might obscure the association. Complete data were available for 671 of the 865 eligible persons (574 who undertook the follow-up examination and 97 who did not participate at follow-up but had adequate information for cognitive diagnosis). A flow chart that details the sample derivation is shown in Figure 1
.
|
Laboratory investigations
At baseline, fasting venous blood samples were taken; they were immediately sent to the biochemical laboratory for processing. Serum folate and vitamin B-12 were measured with the use of immediate immunoelectrochemiluminescence analysis (Elecsys Folate Immunoassay and Elecsys B12 Immunoassay for Elecsys 2010 System; Roche Diagnostics Italia SpA, Monza, Italy). Serum total cholesterol and triacylglycerols were measured with the use of an enzymatic assay (Roche Diagnostics) on a Hitachi 917 System autoanalyzer (Boehringer Mannheim, Mannheim, Germany). Serum creatinine was measured by using the Jaffé method adapted for autoanalyzers. Serum CRP was measured with the use of the Nhigh-sensitivity CRP assay on a BN II analyzer (Dade Behring, Milan, Italy). Plasma tHcy was measured with the automated IMx assay (Abbott Laboratories, Abbott Park, IL) on plasma samples stored at 70 °C for
12 mo. Intraassay and interassay CVs for homocysteine, serum B vitamins, and serum CRP were reported in detail elsewhere (14, 26).
Apolipoprotein E genotypes
A commercial kit (QiAmp blood kit; Kaga, Crawley, United Kingdom) was used for genomic DNA extraction. Standardized polymerase chain reaction protocols were used for genotyping of APOE (27) and the 677 (C
T) polymorphism of the gene was used for methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase (MTHFR) (28), a key enzyme in homocysteine metabolism. The variant T/T genotype is associated with the highest homocysteine concentrations under conditions of impaired folate status (29). Subjects were categorized as carriers or noncarriers of APOE4 and 677 MTHFR T/T genotypes.
Covariates
Covariates were selected on the basis of preliminary analyses (14, 28) and previous reports of homocysteine determinants (16, 17, 29) and were defined with the use of data collected at baseline. Educational status was categorized as 3 y compared with
4 y of formal education, because only a few participants had completed 5 y of formal education. Smoking habit was categorized as never smokers, ex-smokers, and current smokers. Physical activity was categorized as sedentary or active lifestyle, defined as performing at least moderate physical activity for a minimum of 4 h/wk. Diagnoses of cardiovascular disease (myocardial infarction, angina, peripheral vascular disease, congestive heart failure) and stroke were based on medical history provided by the patients and confirmed by their physicians. When available, previous medical records were also reviewed. Body mass index (in kg/m2) was calculated.
Statistical analysis
Continuous variables are presented as means ± SDs, and categorical variables (except plasma tHcy, serum folate, serum vitamin B-12, and serum CRP because of their highly skewed distribution) are presented as number and percentage. Natural logtransformed values provided the best-fitting model for analyses in which plasma tHcy, serum folate, and serum vitamin B-12 were treated as continuous variables, and values were reported as geometric means and 95% CIs. Hyperhomocysteinemia was defined as plasma tHcy >15 µmol/L (14), which corresponds to the standard definition for hyperhomocysteinemia by international consensus (29). Because combined B vitamin deficits are more influential as a cause of hyperhomocysteinemia than are single deficits (16), we created a B vitamin index of 4 categories, based on the median value of each serum vitamin: combined B vitamin depletion (serum folate
5.3 ng/mL and serum vitamin B-12
341 pg/mL), selective folate depletion (serum folate
5.3 ng/mL and serum vitamin B-12 >341 pg/mL), selective vitamin B-12 depletion (serum folate >5.3 ng/mL and serum vitamin B-12
341 pg/mL), and B vitamin repletion (serum folate >5.3 ng/mL and serum vitamin B-12 >341 pg/mL). These thresholds fall near the upper limits of the range at which plasma tHcy is reported to begin increasing steeply [serum folate: 34.4 ng/mL (710 nmol/L); vitamin B-12: 271339 pg/mL (200250 pmol/L)] (29). As expected (16), the highest mean plasma concentration of tHcy (approximately corresponding to the cutoff for hyperhomocysteinemia) was found for combined B vitamin depletion (Table 1
).
|
We used t tests and chi-square tests for comparisons between groups. Factorial analysis [2 x 3 analysis of variance (ANOVA)] was used to assess the effect of APOE4, high CRP, and B vitamin status (categorical) on plasma tHcy. Because our primary concern was the concurrent effect of these variables on homocysteinemia, the most relevant statistics were the interaction terms APOE4x B vitamin status and APOE4x high CRP. In the event of a statistically significant interaction term, Tukey's test for all pairwise comparisons was used to compare the subgroups obtained, by stratifying the sample for both the variables included in the interaction term. The ANOVA model was also tested after adjustment for possible confounders. A first group of confounders (model 1) included all the study covariates giving a statistically significant contribution to the model (ie, age, sex, education, serum concentration of creatinine, physical activity, cardiovascular disease, stroke, and baseline MMSE). A second group of confounders (model 2) included all the variables of model 1 along with other variables that were biologically important variables without statistically significant effect on the model (ie, smoking habit, serum concentrations of total cholesterol and triacylglycerols, body mass index, and MTHFR genotype).
The effect of APOE4 on CRP as a continuous variable could not be analyzed by using a factorial ANOVA design because of the failure to normalize its skewed distribution. However, the OR and 95% CI for the association of APOE4 (dependent variable) with high CRP and hyperhomocysteinemia (independent variables) were estimated by using a logistic regression model that also included the interaction term high CRP x hyperhomocysteinemia. The interaction term was again the most relevant statistic of this analysis because our primary aim was to investigate whether and how each of the variables affected the association of APOE4 with the other. In the event of the interaction term's being significant, ORs were estimated from the model according to the procedure described by Hosmer and Lemeshow (31). For this analysis, homocysteine was treated as a categorical variable to make it easier for the reader to understand the meaning of the ORs. Results were also tested by running additional logistic models adjusted for B vitamin status (categorical) and all of the other covariates used for multivariable adjustment of the ANOVA models. In preliminary analyses, the logistic model was also checked for interactions between B vitamin status (both as a categorical variable and as continuous log-transformed serum folate and vitamin B-12) and all the variables of interest. However, these interactions were not included in the final analysis because they were not significant (P > 0.200 for all) (31). Statistical analyses were performed with the use of SYSTAT software (version 10; SPSS Inc, Chicago, IL). Statistical significance was set at P < 0.050.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
Information was also available about baseline alcohol and caffeine intakes, serum thyrotropin and plasma pyridoxal-5'-phosphate, diabetes, hypertension, and the use of nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs and statins. Adjustment for these additional variables did not alter the results (data not shown).
Association of APOE4 with high serum C-reactive protein and effect of hyperhomocysteinemia
The unadjusted logistic model that examined the simultaneous association of high CRP and hyperhomocysteinemia with APOE4 confirmed that the condition of being an APOE4 carrier was associated with a lower risk of both high CRP (OR = 0.57; 95% CI: 0.36, 0.91) and hyperhomocysteinemia (OR = 0.25; 95% CI: 0.10, 0.65) than was the condition of being a noncarrier. However, the high CRP x hyperhomocysteinemia interaction term was also significant (P = 0.034) and remained so after multivariate adjustment (P < 0.05 for both models 1 and 2), which indicatied the need to estimate separate ORs for each variable stratified by the other. As shown in Table 4
, the probability of high CRP was lower for APOE4 carriers than for noncarriers only if the carriers were without hyperhomocysteinemia. Conversely, in agreement with the results from the ANOVA model, the probability of hyperhomocysteinemia was lower for APOE4 carriers than for noncarriers but only if the carriers were without high CRP. Among subjects with both high CRP and hyperhomocysteinemia, the prevalence of high CRP tended to be higher in APOE4 carriers than in noncarriers, but the association was not significant.
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A possible explanation for our findings is that, as has been hypothesized for VLDL-bound CRP (5), APOE4 affects the clearance of the lipoprotein-bound homocysteine fraction. Approximately 80% of homocysteine circulates in blood bound to proteins, with albumin as the main carrier (29). However,
27% of all protein-bound homocysteine circulates bound to lipoproteins, and VLDL has the highest binding capacity, possibly because of its apolipoprotein B content (1820). APOE4 carriers have the highest apolipoprotein B concentrations and are particularly efficient in clearing VLDL from blood (1, 2). Therefore, under conditions leading to hyperhomocysteinemia, APOE4 carriers may have greater binding of homocysteine to lipoproteins, a faster clearance of the lipoprotein-bound homocysteine fraction, or both. Further support to the hypothesis is the fact that the association of APOE4 with a lower risk of hyperhomocysteinemia weakens under conditions of high CRP, whereas the association of APOE4 with a lower risk of high CRP weakens under conditions of hyperhomocysteinemia. These facts combine to suggest that CRP and homocysteine may compete for the same mechanism (perhaps a lipoprotein carrier) that favors their blood clearance in APOE4 carriers. Alternatively, APOE4 may be in linkage disequilibrium with other unknown genes that are able to affect both homocysteine and CRP metabolism.
The results that 1) the highest homocysteine concentration was actually found in APOE4 noncarriers with low CRP and 2) APOE4 carriers with high CRP had average homocysteine concentrations not significantly different from those in both APOE4 carriers and noncarriers with low high CRP may seem inconsistent with the hypothesis that high CRP attenuates the homocysteine-lowering effect of APOE4. However, by looking at the percentage of subjects with hyperhomocysteinemia in each group, it can be observed that the figures for subjects with high CRP and for APOE4 noncarriers with low CRP are almost 3 times the figures for APOE4 carriers with low CRP. Therefore, it may be speculated that, above a certain threshold of homocysteinemia, the hypothesized APOE4-related mechanism for removal of the homocysteine-lipid bound fraction is saturated, and other, more efficient, catabolic pathways are activated. That possibility may explain why the subjects with high CRP had lower homocysteinemia than expected: that is, the concurrent presence of high CRP so attenuates the efficiency of lipid-bound homocysteine removal that, independently of APOE, additional catabolic pathways are triggered. At the same time, that possibility may justify the unexpectedly high homocysteinemia found in APOE4 noncarriers with low CRP: that is, they lack the APOE4-related advantage for removal of the homocysteine lipid-bound quote, but their low CRP does not interfere with the normal VLDL or VLDL-like mechanism, so the threshold for activation of the additional mechanisms is not reached. Of course, because of the scant numbers in the APOE4 carrier subgroups, it cannot be excluded that the post hoc all-pairwise comparison test failed to identify existent significant differences.
No association between homocysteinemia and APOE4 was reported in previous investigations of Polish (33) or adult Taiwanese (34) subjects. Those investigations, however, were not specifically focused on the association of interest, and they had small population sizes. Differences in APOE4 frequencies related to differences in the ethnic origin of the samples (1) and to the selection criteria used for the present investigationthat is, APOE4 and other genotypes associated with risk of cognitive impairment are likely to be underrepresented in this study sample because of the exclusion of subject with prevalent and incident dementiaand to the better B vitamin status of the Polish population may have contributed to the different results obtained in those studies.
The main strengths of the current investigation are its population size, the large number of covariates available in the CSBA database, and the specific selection of persons free of dementia both at baseline and after a 4-y follow-up, which avoids the confounding effect of known associations between cognitive status and the variables of interest. The study, however, has several limitations. First, results for the analysis examining the interactions of hyperhomocysteinemia and CRP in their association with APOE4 are based on relatively small numbers of subjects. Second, because of its skewed distribution, CRP could be analyzed only as a categorical variable. Third, serum folate and vitamin B-12 are not the best indicators of metabolic vitamin deficiency, and other unmeasured vitamins may influence homocysteine metabolism (35). Fourth, only a single measurement of laboratory values was available. Fifth, although APOE4, homocysteine, and CRP are all associated with a greater risk of atherosclerotic events, we did not systematically excluded persons with vascular disease. The CSBA design did not include an assessment of cardiovascular conditions beyond clinical diagnosis, and it relied on data provided by participants and their physicians. Moreover, incident atherothrombotic events were not actively sought among those persons who refused to participate or who died before follow-up. However, the presence of vascular conditions at baseline was considered among the covariates, and inclusion of incident vascular events in the models as an additional covariate did not substantially change the results (data not shown). Sixth, although we did not genotype the cohort for known CRP genetic polymorphisms, evidence suggests that these polymorphisms have no effect on the association between APOE4 and serum CRP (6). Seventh, it may be speculated that the somewhat paradoxical association between a genetic risk factor for dementia and the lower concentrations of putative dementia risk factors that we found in this sample is the reason that the APOE4 carriers included in the study did not develop dementia during follow-up. In particular, it would have been interesting to verify whether the association was also present in the CSBA subjects who were cognitively normal at baseline but who received a diagnosis of dementia at follow-up and were excluded from the present investigation. However, the smallness of the latter group (only 12 subjects with full laboratory data) did not allow any reliable statistical analysis, and further studies on larger samples and with longer follow-up time are needed to investigate the hypothesis that blood concentrations of homocysteine and CRP may affect the risk of Alzheimer dementia associated with APOE4. A larger study sample is also needed to look for a confirmation of the nonsignificant trend we observed, under condition of hyperhomocysteinemia, for APOE4 carriers to have a higher prevalence of high CRP than noncarriers, because these subjects may be at greater risk of dementia.
In conclusion, this study suggests that, in comparison with noncarriers, APOE4 carriers have, independently from B vitamin status, a lower risk of hyperhomocysteinemia and of high CRP. However, the presence of one condition attenuates the association of APOE4 with the other, and it cannot be excluded that, for substantial increases in CRP and homocysteine, their hypothesized competition at a common APOE4-related mechanism may be bypassed by the intervention of other, more efficient elimination pathways. Given the growing interest of researchers in homocysteine and CRP as risk factors for vascular events and dementia (2, 3, 810), our results suggest the need to take the APOE genotype into account in future studies that involve blood measurement of these markers.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
GR, PF, and FMa were responsible for the conception and design of the study; GR was responsible for obtaining the funds for the study; GR is responsible for the integrity of the data and the accuracy of the data analysis; PF, MC, and FMa were responsible for data collection; PF and FMo were responsible for data analysis, with the assistance of MC, FMa, and CP; GR, PF, and FMa were responsible for drafting the manuscript; and FL, MB, and CP contributed to the revision of the manuscript. None of the authors had a financial or personal conflict of interest.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
1-antichymotrypsin and interleukin-1 plasma levels increases Alzheimer's disease risk. Ann Neurol 2000;48:38891.[Medline]
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |