|
|
||||||||
ORIGINAL RESEARCH COMMUNICATION |
1 From the Division of Nutrition, St John's Research Institute, St John's National Academy of Health Sciences, Bangalore, India (PT, SM, and AVK), and the Human Nutrition Laboratory, Institute of Food Science and Nutrition, Swiss Federal Institute of Technology Zurich, Switzerland (TW and RFH)
2 Supported by the International Atomic Energy Agency, The Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, and St John's National Academy of Health Sciences. 3 Reprints not available. Address correspondence to S Muthayya, Division of Nutrition, St John's Research Institute, St John's National Academy of Health Sciences, Bangalore, India. E-mail: sumithra{at}iphcr.res.in.
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Objective: We evaluated the influence of the iron status of young women on iron absorption from a rice meal with or without added tea or AA.
Design: Two stable-isotope iron absorption studies were made in 2 groups of 10 subjects with iron deficiency anemia (IDA) and 10 subjects who were iron replete (control subjects). In study 1, the reference rice meal was fed alone or with 1 or 2 cups of black tea. In study 2, the reference meal was fed alone or with AA (molar ratio to iron, 2:1 or 4:1). Iron absorption was measured by the erythrocyte incorporation of 57Fe and 58Fe labels at 14 d.
Results: Mean fractional iron absorption from the reference rice meal was
2.5 times as great in the IDA group as in the control group (P < 0.05). The consumption of 1 or 2 cups of tea decreased iron absorption in the control subjects by 49% (P < 0.05) or 66% (P < 0.01), respectively, and in the IDA group by 59% or 67% (P < 0.001 for both), respectively. AA (molar ratio to iron, 2:1 or 4:1) increased iron absorption by 270% or 343%, respectively, in control subjects and by 291% or 350%, respectively, in subjects with IDA (P < 0.001).
Conclusions: The inhibitory effect of tea and the enhancing effect of AA on iron absorption were similar in the 2 groups. Overall differences in iron absorption in the 2 groups, however, continued to be dictated by iron status.
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Individual dietary inhibitory and enhancing factors exert profound influences on iron absorption (8–10). The potent inhibitory effect of phytic acid on nonheme-iron absorption is well known (11–13). Polyphenolic compounds such as chlorogenic acids, monomeric flavonoids, and polyphenol polymerization products widely present in coffee and tea also strongly inhibit dietary nonheme-iron absorption (14–16). The effects of ascorbic acid (AA) in dramatically improving iron absorption have consistently been observed (17–19). Heme iron found in animal foods is also an important iron source because of its high bioavailability (20). In addition, many studies have suggested that the enhancing effect of muscle tissue on iron absorption is due to cysteine-containing peptides (21–23).
Another physiologic factor that plays a major role in the amount of iron absorbed is the iron status of a person. Several studies have reported an inverse relation between body iron stores and iron absorption: that is, more iron is absorbed in an iron-deficient state and less iron is absorbed in an iron-replete state (24–26). Some reports on iron absorption showed it to be similar across a range of iron stores (26–28). These studies used mainly iron-replete subjects but also subjects with low iron stores, and, hence, the extent to which iron absorption responds to the presence of enhancers or inhibitors in subjects with IDA is not clear. Such information is crucial to an understanding of how modifying dietary enhancers and inhibitors could improve iron status in malnourished populations. The present studies used stable-isotope techniques to study whether iron absorption from a rice meal with or without added tea or AA would differ between iron-deficient anemic women and women with normal iron status.
| SUBJECTS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Forty women were selected on the basis of their hemoglobin and iron status and the absence of inflammation or infection during the initial screening. The criteria for the IDA group were hemoglobin values < 11.0 g/dL, serum ferritin (SF) concentrations < 12 µg/L, and zinc protoporphyrin concentrations > 40 µmol/mol heme or soluble transferrin receptors (TfRs) > 8.5 mg/L; criteria for the control group were hemoglobin values > 12.0 g/dL and measures of iron status (SF, zinc protoporphyrin, and TfRs) in the normal range. At the close of study, all IDA group subjects were supplemented with ferrous sulfate according to the standard of care.
Written informed consent was obtained from all women after they were given a full oral and written description of the aims and procedures of the study and the associated risks. The experimental protocol was approved by the ethics committees of St John's Medical College (Bangalore, India) and the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology (Zurich, Switzerland).
Test meals
Test meal preparation and composition
The reference meal consisted of a rice meal (tomato rice), which was designed so that it contained small amounts of both enhancers and inhibitors of iron absorption (Table 1
). The meal was prepared in a single large batch for all subjects in both studies, divided into individual weighed portions (200 g), and kept frozen at –80 °C until use. All ingredients were weighed out. Oil was heated in a pan, and tomato purée was added and sautéed in the oil for 5 min. Turmeric, chili powder, and salt were added to the purée while it was constantly stirred. Rice was added into this mixture, which was stirred over heat for a further 2 min. Finally, water was added, and the mixture was cooked with constant stirring until done. All of the utensils used in the preparation and cooking were made of either aluminum or plastic, and they had been washed with filtered water and dried before use.
|
|
Study design
Each subject received 2 reference rice meals (meal A) and 2 test meals (one each of B and C) that were labeled with either 57Fe or 58Fe, as shown in Table 2
. Within each study, a randomized crossover study design was used, in which each subject acted as her own control. Each subject was assigned to meals A and B or A and C on paired test days 1 and 2 and 15 and 16, so that each pair of meal administrations always had reference meal A with test meal B or reference meal A with test meal C. Reference meal A was always labeled with 57Fe. The added iron in test meals B and C was labeled with 58Fe. Iron absorption was based on the erythrocyte incorporation of isotope labels 14 d after intake of the iron-labeled reference and test meals.
On all study days, subjects reported to the laboratory in a fasted state. On day 1, body weight was measured to the nearest 0.1 kg (Soehnle, Murrhardt, Germany), and height was measured to the nearest 1.0 cm by using a stadiometer. After these measurements, subjects consumed the first meal (A). The test meal containers were washed 3 times with 10 mL ultrapure water to ensure complete consumption of the meal and the isotope label. No intake of food or fluids was allowed for 3 h thereafter. The second meal (B or C) was administered the next day (day 2) under identical conditions. A venous blood sample was drawn 14 d after the second meal to measure isotopic composition. The second pair of reference and test meals (A and B or C) was administered on days 15 and 16, respectively, under conditions identical to those on days 1 and 2. A final blood sample was drawn on day 29, 14 d after the second pair of meal administrations, to measure isotopic composition. All test meals were administered as a breakfast meal under supervision.
Stable-isotope labels
The preparation of the isotopic labels was similar to the method described by Walczyk et al (30). Briefly, the labels of [57Fe]-FeSO4 and [58Fe]-FeSO4 were prepared from isotopically enriched elemental iron (57Fe at 95.9% enrichment and 58Fe at 93.2% enrichment: Chemgas, Boulogne, France) by dissolution in 0.1-mol H2SO4/L solution. The isotopic composition of the iron in solution was determined by using negative thermal ionization–mass spectrometry. Iron concentrations were measured by isotope dilution–mass spectrometry against an iron standard prepared gravimetrically from an iron isotope reference material (IRM-014; EU Institute of Reference Material, Geel, Belgium). The dose was calculated on the basis of the estimated amount of circulating iron in the subjects, the expected range of fractional iron absorption, and the attainable precision of the isotopic analysis. The administered dose was determined by weighing the test meal before and after the isotope label was sprayed onto the test meal.
Measurements of hemoglobin and iron status
Hemoglobin concentrations were measured in whole blood by using a Coulter counter (AcT Diff2; Beckman Coulter, Krefeld, Germany) with 3-level quality-control material (Liquichek; Bio-Rad, Irvine, CA). SF and TfRs were calculated by using commercial enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (Ramco Laboratories, Stafford, TX) in plasma samples. Assays were calibrated by using the standards provided by the manufacturer (Ramco Laboratories for SF and purified TfR solutions). World Health Organization–traceable quality-control material (Ramco Laboratories) was processed with each batch of samples for validation of the SF assay. C-reactive protein was measured in plasma samples by using a particle-enhanced turbidimetric immunoassay (Dimension RXL Chemistry Analyzer; Dade, Deerfield, IL). Control materials (Lyphocheck; Bio-Rad) were analyzed within each run. Zinc protoporphyrin was measured in red blood cells after the cells were washed with normal saline with the use of a hematofluorometer (Aviv Biomedical, Lakewood, NJ) and 3-level control material provided by the manufacturer. Measurements were made in stored refrigerated blood within 1 d of collection.
Isotopic analysis of the blood samples
The method used to analyze the enriched blood samples was similar to our previously described technique (31). All isotopic analysis was carried on a negative thermal ionization–mass spectrometer (MAT 262; Finnigan MAT, Bremen, Germany) equipped with a multicollector system for simultaneous ion beam detection.
Calculations
The amount of circulating label was calculated on the basis of the shift in the isotopic ratios and the amount of circulating iron in the blood. Calculations were based on principles of dilution, and the nonmonoisotopic nature of the labels was taken into consideration (31). Circulating iron was calculated on the basis of blood volume and hemoglobin concentration; 80% incorporation of the absorbed iron into erythrocytes was assumed. The observed shift in iron isotope ratios was converted to fractional iron absorption by using standard algorithms (31). The shift in isotope ratios measured on day 15 was used as a new baseline for measurement of isotope ratio shifts on day 29.
Statistical analysis
All statistical analyses were conducted with SPSS statistical software (version 13; SPSS Inc, Chicago, IL). Iron absorption values were logarithmically transformed for statistical analysis. To account for intraindividual and interindividual variations in iron absorption, iron absorption from a given test meal (with added tea or AA solution) was normalized to iron absorption from the reference meal in each individual subject. This study design with 10 subjects per study group had 80% power to detect a significant difference of 50% in iron absorption between 2 test meals with a significance level of 0.05. Paired student's t tests were used to test differences between iron absorption from the reference meal with or without tea or AA within the IDA and control groups. Comparisons of iron absorption between IDA and control subjects were made by using the unpaired Student's t test. For identification of a dose-response effect, absorption ratios were compared between study intervals by using a paired Student's t test. Differences were considered significant at P < 0.05.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
Test meal: effect of ascorbic acid
When added to the meal at a molar ratio to iron of 2:1, AA increased iron absorption by 291% in the IDA group and by 270% in the control group (P < 0.001 for both). A further increase in iron absorption was observed in both the groups with AA added at a molar ratio to iron of 4:1 (350% and 343%, respectively; P < 0.001 for both). A dose-related effect between the 2 levels of AA intake, however, was not observed in either of the iron status groups. Comparison of absorption ratios between the different iron status groups showed no significant differences in the enhancing effect of AA between IDA and controls, which indicated that the enhancing effect is likely to be independent of iron status.
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2.5 times (range: 1.8–3.7) as high in IDA subjects than in control subjects in the present study, in association with meals with or without enhancers or inhibitors of iron absorption, which showed that body iron status primarily dictates the physiologic demand for iron. Several studies have shown the inverse relation that exists between iron stores and nonheme-iron absorption in humans (24–26). This is due to increases or decreases in iron absorption at the mucosal surface brought about by modulation of the expression of DMTI and other iron transport proteins according to the iron stores (38, 39). Hepcidin is also thought to play a regulatory role in iron metabolism by directly affecting the ferroportin transporter within the mucosal basolateral membrane and by preventing iron efflux into the blood (40). Higher iron absorption values have been reported in blood donors with low iron stores than in nondonors (41). However, there are indications from other studies that the effects of enhancers and inhibitors are probably independent of iron status (26–28). In long-term studies, adaptive responses were observed in iron-replete subjects given meals with low and high iron bioavailability, to which they adapted by absorbing less iron from the high-bioavailability diet and more iron from the low-bioavailability diet, so as to stay in balance (27). Our results confirm earlier findings that tea inhibits iron absorption to a considerable extent (14, 16). In our study, we observed a 50–70% reduction in iron absorption with the addition of either 78 or 156 mg polyphenols in black tea to the rice meal. This strong interaction between iron and polyphenols in the tea within the gut lumen was irrespective of iron status. Fractional iron absorption, in absolute terms, however, was higher in the IDA subjects consuming either amount of tea than in the control subjects, proportional to the existing higher absorption in this group. Our results also indicated that, in the IDA group, there was no further inhibition of iron absorption with the consumption of >1 cup of tea, whereas, in the control subjects, a dose effect of the 2 amounts of tea was observed. This suggests a stronger physicochemical interaction of polyphenols and iron in the gut for a given amount of tea in the IDA subjects. However, the possibility that a dose effect was not observed because of an inadequate sample size cannot be disregarded. In the early 1970s, Disler et al (14) found a significant inhibitory effect of tea on iron absorption from iron salts (FeCl3 and FeSO4), bread, a rice meal, or uncooked hemoglobin; they ascribed this finding to the effective sequestration of a good proportion of the iron in unabsorbable tannin complexes. More recently, the effects of different polyphenol-containing beverages on iron absorption from a bread meal were estimated by Hurrell et al (16) from the erythrocyte incorporation of radio-iron. All beverages reduced iron absorption depending on the content of total polyphenols, with the inhibition of black tea the greatest at 79–94%. Amounts of only 20 mg polyphenols from black tea per meal reduced iron absorption by as much as 66%, possibly because of the higher content of galloyl esters in black tea and possibly because the simple bread meal was devoid of any enhancers of iron absorption to counteract the polyphenols.
The strong enhancing effect of AA on iron absorption observed in the present study confirms previous evidence that AA increases iron absorption in a variety of meals (8, 18, 42–45). The increase in absorption due to the addition of AA was similar in both iron status groups. As observed in study 1, absolute absorption values in the IDA group were significantly higher and proportional to the increase due to the lower iron status. No significant dose-response effects of AA when added at molar ratios of 2:1 and 4:1 relative to iron on iron absorption were noted in either group—again, possibly because of the small sample size or a ceiling effect on absorption even at a molar ratio of 2:1. With a more inhibitory meal, this lack of dose-response effect might not have been seen. Single-meal studies, such as the present one, have been criticized because they tend to exaggerate the effect of enhancers of iron absorption.
Long-term controlled trials have reported conflicting results with respect to changes in iron status after increasing dietary AA intake, which indicate more physiologic complexity (46–49). In those studies, the effects either were not seen or were far less than those seen in single-meal studies. One study carried out in Mexico, in which limeade containing 25 mg AA was added twice daily to typical Mexican meals for 2 wk, showed that iron absorption increased in iron-deficient women by as much as 345% (50); the effect was significantly stronger with increasing severity of iron deficiency. Two studies done at the population level also showed that, in children, AA supplementation taken with meals improved the children's iron status (49, 51). The Indian diet, with its abundance of phytate and polyphenolic compounds, is likely to make iron more available for absorption when supplemented with AA-rich foods. Improving AA intake in the form of fruit and citrus juice in the diet could be a culturally relevant and practical approach to improving iron status in Indian populations; studies on the adaptive effects of greater AA intake on both iron absorption and status have the potential to develop future dietary interventions. Therefore, long-term studies of the adaptability of iron absorption in response to enhancement of food components are clearly needed in the Indian context.
In conclusion, fractional iron absorption in Indian women was relatively high from a simple rice meal. The strong inhibitory effect of tea and the beneficial effects of AA on iron absorption were of a similar magnitude in iron-replete women and women with IDA. Overall differences in iron absorption in the 2 groups, however, continued to be dictated by iron status. Dietary modifications could perhaps be used to address the needs of iron-deficient women in this population.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
The authors' responsibilities were as follows—all authors: contributed to the study design and to the data and statistical analyses; PT, SM, and TW: supervised and carried out the isotopic studies; PT: wrote the first draft of the paper; and all authors: contributed to the editing of the manuscript. None of the authors had a personal or financial conflict of interest.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |