|
|
||||||||
ORIGINAL RESEARCH COMMUNICATION |
1 From the Gerontological Research Programme (TPN, LF, MN, KBT, and EHK) and the Department of Psychological Medicine (TPN, LF, MN, EHK), University of Singapore, Singapore, and the Department of Geriatric Medicine, Alexandra Hospital, Singapore (KBY)
2 Supported by research grant no. 03/1/21/17/214 from the Biomedical Research Council, Agency for Science, Technology and Research (ASTAR).
3 Reprints not available. Address correspondence to T-P Ng, Gerontological Research Programme, National University of Singapore, Department of Psychological Medicine, National University Hospital, 5 Lower Kent Ridge Road, Singapore 119074. E-mail: pcmngtp{at}nus.edu.sg.
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Objective: We aimed to examine the relation between tea intake and cognitive impairment and decline.
Design: Among community-living Chinese adults aged
55 y in the Singapore Longitudinal Ageing Studies cohort, we measured tea consumption at baseline and administered the Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE) at baseline and 1–2 y later. Cognitive impairment was defined as an MMSE score
23 and cognitive decline as a drop in MMSE score of
1 point. We performed cross-sectional analysis of baseline data from 2501 participants and longitudinal analysis of data from 1438 cognitively intact participants. Odds ratios (ORs) of association were calculated in logistic regression models that adjusted for potential confounders.
Results: Total tea intake was significantly associated with a lower prevalence of cognitive impairment, independent of other risk factors. Compared with the ORs for rare or no tea intake, the ORs for low, medium, and high levels of tea intake were 0.56 (95% CI: 0.40, 0.78), 0.45 (95% CI: 0.27, 0.72), and 0.37 (95% CI: 0.14, 0.98), respectively (P for trend < 0.001). For cognitive decline, the corresponding ORs were 0.74 (95% CI: 0.54, 1.00), 0.78 (95% CI: 0.55, 1.11), and 0.57 (95% CI: 0.32, 1.03), respectively (P for trend = 0.042). These effects were most evident for black (fermented) and oolong (semi-fermented) teas, the predominant types consumed by this population. In contrast, no association between coffee intake and cognitive status was found.
Conclusion: Regular tea consumption was associated with lower risks of cognitive impairment and decline.
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
4000–5000 y ago. Today, 3 billion cups of tea are consumed every day by millions of people all over the world. All varieties and cultivars of the tea plant belong to a single species, Camellia sinensis (1). The most widely used classification of tea of biological and health relevance is based on the degree of fermentation and oxidization of polyphenols in fresh tea leaves. Although 6 types of teas are distinguished, including flower-scented and reprocessed tea (2), the 3 main types of tea are black tea (fully fermented), oolong tea (semi-fermented), and green tea (nonfermented). Black tea accounts for
72% of the world's total tea production. During the fermentation process, 2 groups of polyphenol compounds, theaflavins and thearubigins, are formed as a result of enzymatic oxidation by polyphenol oxidase of catechins (2). Therefore, the content of tea polyphenols differs for each tea because of the different degrees of fermentation during manufacture, as well as differences in place of origin and plant cultivars. Besides tea polyphenols, tea leaf contains theanine, caffeine, and other chemical components.
In recent decades, experimental and epidemiologic studies have associated tea with a wide variety of health benefits, such as the prevention of cardiovascular diseases (3–5), cancer (6–8), and mortality (9). Although the findings are somewhat inconsistent, most appear to support tea's favorable effects. Nonhuman experimental data suggest that tea has neuroprotective effects (10–12). Recently, a cross-sectional study in an elderly Japanese population observed that higher consumption of green tea but not of black or oolong tea was associated with a lower prevalence of cognitive impairment (13). No study has yet supported or refuted this finding. In the present study, we analyzed cross-sectional and longitudinal data of a population cohort of older Chinese adults in the Singapore Longitudinal Ageing Studies (SLAS) to determine the association between the levels of tea intake and cognitive impairment and cognitive decline and to explore possible differential effects of specific types of tea.
| SUBJECTS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
55 y were identified from a door-to-door census and invited to participate in the study. Nonparticipants included those who were unable to complete the interview because they were too frail or terminally ill, such as those with stroke aphasia and profound dementia (8.5%), or they refused or could not be contacted (13.2%).
A total of 2808 participants provided baseline data from September 2003 to December 2005. Among them, we omitted the small numbers of non-Chinese (Malays and Indians) and identified 2607 Chinese participants for the present study. Cross-sectional analysis was performed on the data of 2501 participants, after excluding 106 participants with missing cognitive or tea intake data (or both). Of 2194 participants without cognitive impairment [Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE) total score
24] at baseline, cognitive function was reassessed after 1–2 y (median: 16 mo) in 1438 subjects (65.5%).
All participants provided written informed consent (response rate: 78.2%). The study was approved by National University of Singapore Institutional Review Board.
Cognitive performance
Cognitive function was assessed by the MMSE (14), which measures global cognitive functioning in domains that included memory, attention, language, praxis, and visuospatial ability; we used the Chinese version of the MMSE that was externally validated for local use in another study population of older Singaporean adults (15). The MMSE was coded according to previous conventions: items were coded as zero if the subjects refused or were unable to complete. Summed scores from the MMSE ranged from 0 to 30; higher values denote better cognitive functioning. Cognitive impairment was defined by an MMSE total score of
23, which was previously shown to have high sensitivity (95.5%) and specificity (83.5%) for detecting cases of dementia in older Singaporean Chinese adults. Cognitive decline was defined as a drop of
1 point in the MMSE total score during the interval between baseline assessment and follow-up reassessment.
Tea intake
Detailed information on tea consumption was collected at baseline. The questions were designed according to habitual intake of common types of teas among local elderly by using indigenous references and terms: Ceylon or English tea, Chinese tea, and green tea. Ceylon or English tea is black tea from South Asia (India and Sri Lanka). These black teas are usually consumed with sugar and milk. Chinese tea includes both Chinese black tea and Chinese oolong tea, and it is almost always drunk without sugar or milk.
The frequency of consumption of each type of tea was coded as 0 through 6: never or rarely, <1 cup/wk, >1 cup/wk but <1 cup/d, 1–2 cups/d, 3–5 cups/d, 6–9 cups/d, and
10 cups/d, respectively. One cup was defined as
215 mL, the standard serving size in local cafes. A subject was classified as tea nondrinker if the sum of the 3 scores equalled zero. Low, medium, and high intakes were defined as summed scores from 1 to 3, from 4 to 6, and
7, respectively. For example, if a subject drank <1 cup English (black) tea /wk (coded as 1) or 1–2 cups Chinese black or oolong tea /d (coded as 3), and never drank green tea (coded as 0), the summed score was 1 + 3 + 0 = 4, and the respondent was classified in the medium tea intake group.
Other data
Related data collected at baseline included sociodemographic variables (ie, age, sex, and education), substance use (ie, cigarette smoking and alcohol consumption), coffee consumption, vegetable and fruit consumption ("Do you eat a lot of vegetables and fruits—at least one serving a day?"), fish consumption ("Do you eat a lot of fish—>3 times a week?"), medical conditions, weight, height, blood pressure, and fasting blood glucose. The Geriatric Depression Scale (GDS) (16), which was validated locally (17), was administered as a measure of depression. APOE genotyping was identified by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification followed by restriction endonuclease digestion of the PCR product (PCR-RFLP) (18).
Physical activities were measured by the frequency (0 = never, 1 = sometimes, or 2 = often) with which the respondents engaged in fitness activities such as physical exercise routines, walking, active sports or swimming, and tai chi. Social and productive activities were measured by the frequency (0 = never, 1 = sometimes, or 2 = often) with which the respondents engaged in social activities and productive activities. Social activities included attending religious services, visiting cinemas, restaurants, and sports events, day or excursion trips, playing cards or games, joining in senior citizen club activities, and participating in social group activities, including karaoke and line dancing. Productive activities included hobbies such as gardening, painting, preparing meals, shopping, paid or unpaid community work, and other employment or business. Both the continuous variable (the summed score) and the categorical variable (low, medium, and high level) were created for physical activities and social or productive activities.
Statistical analysis
Differences in characteristics among 4 groups defined by levels of tea intake were evaluated by using a chi-square test (for dichotomous variables) or analysis of variance (for continuous variables). We used hierarchical logistic regression modeling techniques to examine the relation between tea intake and cognitive impairment. The base model (model 1) included levels of tea intake (never, low, medium, or high) as the sole variable. Subsequent models accumulated additional covariates: age, sex, and education (model 2); smoking, alcohol consumption, BMI (continuous), and hypertension, diabetes, heart diseases, and stroke (model 3); and depression, APOE
4, physical activities (as categorical variable), social and productive activities (as categorical variable), vegetable and fruit consumption (
1 serving/d), fish consumption (>3 times/wk), and daily coffee consumption (model 4). Hypertension was defined as systolic blood pressure of >140 mm Hg or diastolic blood pressure of >90 mm Hg or a history of treatment for hypertension. Diabetes mellitus was defined as a fasting blood glucose concentration of
7.0 mmol/L or a history of treatment for diabetes mellitus. Depression was defined as a GDS total score
5.
In the longitudinal data analysis, participants with an MMSE score
23 at baseline were excluded. In multiple logistic regression models for cognitive decline (defined as a drop of
1 point in the MMSE total score), we also adjusted for baseline MMSE total score and the interval between baseline and follow-up.
To explore the differential effects of types of tea on cognitive status, we created 3 categories of tea consumption (tea nondrinker, black or oolong tea drinker, and green tea drinker) and repeated multiple logistic regressions with control for all covariates as above. Because only a small number of participants drank purely green tea (n = 10), a green tea drinker was defined as a participant who consumed green tea with or without black or oolong tea, whereas a black or oolong tea drinker was defined as a participant who consumed black or oolong tea but no green tea.
In detailed analyses examining the dose-effect relation between the intake of black or oolong tea or green tea with cognitive impairment and cognitive decline, we classified the frequency of each type of tea consumption into 3 groups: never or rarely, occasionally, and daily. For example, a respondent was classified as a daily black or oolong tea drinker if he or she consumed either English black or Chinese black or oolong tea daily and as a black or oolong tea nondrinker if he or she never or rarely drank English black or Chinese black or oolong tea; the rest were grouped as occasional black or oolong tea drinkers. For contrast, we also examined the relation between coffee intake (never or rarely, occasionally, or daily) and cognitive status.
Interactions between tea intake and sex and age were tested through the addition of cross-product terms to the regression model. The results are also presented for stratified analyses by sex and age (<75 y and
75 y). All the statistical tests were 2-sided, and P < 0.05 was regarded as significant. All data analysis was conducted with the use of SPSS software (version 15.0; SPSS Inc, Chicago, IL).
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
40% drank English black tea. Less than 24% of the study population habitually consumed green tea, and the proportion of daily consumers was <7% (Table 1
|
1 point in the MMSE score (
± SD drop: 1.94 ± 1.27 points).
In univariate analysis, higher levels of total tea consumption were significantly associated with higher MMSE total scores and a lower prevalence of cognitive impairment (Table 2
). However, higher tea consumption levels also were associated with younger age, lower proportions of women, higher education level, higher proportions of alcohol drinkers, and a lower prevalence of depression (Table 2
). Moreover, participants who consumed more tea had higher levels of physical activities and social or productive activities, and they tended to consume more vegetables and fruit and fish.
|
|
|
|
75 y), the ORs of the association of tea drinking with cognitive impairment and cognitive decline appeared to be homogeneous for both men and women and for both younger and older seniors. | DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
55 y, we found that more frequent tea consumption of all kinds was associated with a lower risk of cognitive impairment and cognitive decline. The association was particularly clearly evident for black or oolong tea, which was the predominant type of tea consumed. Although the possible cognitive protective effect of tea has been reported in experimental animal models (19–21), it was only recently that one other human study reported an association of higher green tea consumption with a lower prevalence of cognitive impairment in elderly Japanese (13). However, the cross-sectional design of that study limits inference of a temporal causal relation. The present study included both cross-sectional and longitudinal analyses and thus provides stronger support of a temporal relation.
The present study agrees with the Tsurugaya Project study (13), which reported an inverse association of green tea drinking with cognitive impairment. We found an inverse association of black or oolong tea drinking with both cognitive impairment and cognitive decline. Although our cross-sectional analysis supported an association of green tea with less cognitive impairment, this association cannot be meaningfully separated from that due to black or oolong tea, given the small numbers of those who drank green tea only.
There is a great difference in tea drinking habits between the 2 study populations in Singapore and Japan. The elderly Chinese in this population consume vastly more black and oolong tea than green tea. Most (72%) of the Japanese study participants consumed >2 cups green tea/d (1 cup was defined as 0.1 L), whereas, of our Chinese population, only 6.28% consumed
1 cup green tea/d (1 cup defined as 0.215 L). The frequency of tea consumption appeared to be more heterogeneous among elderly Chinese than among elderly Japanese. Whereas it was possible in the present study to define a sizeable reference exposure group of tea nondrinkers, the reference exposure group in the Japanese study was constituted of those who consumed <3 cups tea/wk, probably because few if any Japanese were not tea drinkers. These limits direct comparisons of results between the 2 studies.
The underlying mechanisms of the neuroprotective effect of tea are complex. Possible mechanisms regarding tea catechins, especially epigallocatechin gallate (EGCG), may involve their antioxidant and iron-chelating properties, as well as modulation of cell-signaling and cell survival pathways (10, 11). EGCG also could reduce β-amyloid generation by promoting
–secretase cleavage of amyloid precursor protein (22). As for black or oolong tea, because catechins undergo enzymatic transformation during fermentation, the amount of catechins is generally lower than in green tea (23, 24). However, the conversion of catechins to theaflavins during fermentation does not significantly alter their free radical–scavenging activity (25), and both black tea and its components possess strong antioxidative properties (24). Furthermore, both black tea and green tea inhibit human acetylcholinesterase activity (26) and display protective action against β-amyloid–induced toxicity (27). In addition to tea polyphenols, theanine, which is an amino acid uniquely found in tea leaf, may also possess neuroprotective effect (28). Because tea leaf contains various other phytochemicals, including vitamin C, it is possible that the cognitive protective effect of tea is not due to a single compound but rather to the synergistic effect of several or many of its chemical components.
Caffeine is also present in tea leaf, but, because no association between coffee intake and cognitive function was observed in the present analysis, it is less probable that such an association contributes to the observed cognitive protective effect of tea. Although it is generally accepted that the caffeine present in both coffee and tea has effects in quickening reaction time and enhancing performance on vigilance tests, increasing alertness, and improving mood, it remains doubtful whether these changes actually reflect the beneficial effects of caffeine or, rather, the relieving effects after caffeine withdrawal (29). The results of 2 epidemiologic studies of habitual coffee drinkers also are conflicting (30, 31). In contrast, the presence of theanine in tea appears to antagonize the undesirable effects of raised blood pressure, headache, and tiredness associated with caffeine, while enhancing the positive cognitive effects (32).
The strengths of the present study include its longitudinal design and the use of multivariate analyses to control for a large number of potentially confounding risk factors. With the large sample size and the detailed information on tea intake, it was possible to examine dose-response relations. Although tea drinkers showed a more favorable risk profile for cognitive status than did nondrinkers, the inverse association of tea drinking with both cognitive impairment and decline that was consistently found after control for these risk factors suggested that the findings were robust.
The present study had some limitations. Residual and unmeasured confounding is still possible and cannot be excluded. The MMSE has been shown to be a highly reliable and valid measure of cognitive function (33). A drop of
1 points over 1–2 y, commensurate with a drop of
2 points over a longer follow-up of 3 y in other studies (34), is considered to be a substantial decline in cognitive function that is detectable only for a strong risk factor. Hence, small effects on cognitive decline may not be detected with the MMSE (33). The use of an MMSE cutoff of
23 to identify cognitively impaired subjects may include those with dementia, in whom tea drinking could be underestimated, which may bias the results of cross-sectional association with cognitive impairment. Nevertheless, we have re-analyzed the data using MMSE scores as a continuous variable in the analyses, and we found similar relations with cognitive impairment. Moreover, the longitudinal analysis excluded participants with cognitive impairment at baseline and provided firmer supportive evidence of a neuroprotective effect of tea drinking.
The use of a drop of
1 points in MMSE score to define cognitive decline has limitations. By using a drop of
2 points in MMSE score for a more restrictive definition of cognitive decline, we found similar trend of final-model adjusted ORs (95% CI) of association with the level of tea intake—low: 0.82 (0.56, 1.18), medium: 0.77 (0.50, 1.18), and high: 0.66 (0.31, 1.38) intake (P for trend = 0.14). Our data do not exclude a similar, possible beneficial effect of green tea, but the small number of green tea drinkers in the population and the short follow-up did not allow a more rigorous examination of its specificity and dose-response relation with cognitive status.
Cognitive decline predicts the development of dementia and is generally considered a preclinical marker of early dementia (35). The potential effect of tea drinking in protecting against the cognitive decline of advanced age thus has great significance, given the rapid aging of the population and the rising prevalence of vascular and Alzheimer-type dementia. Because tea is cheap, nontoxic, and widely consumed, it has a huge potential effect in promoting cognitive health and perhaps delaying the onset of dementia. Further studies should investigate whether tea consumption lessens the risk of vascular and Alzheimer-type dementia.
In conclusion, regular consumption of tea, particularly black or oolong tea, was associated with lower risks of cognitive impairment and cognitive decline. Further studies should confirm this association and investigate its potential in lessening the risk of dementia.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |