|
|
||||||||
ORIGINAL RESEARCH COMMUNICATION |
1 From the Centre for Vision Research, Department of Ophthalmology and Westmead Millennium Institute, University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia (SK, JJW, VF, JSLT, and PM); the Centre for Eye Research Australia, University of Melbourne, Australia (JJW and TYW); the Human Nutrition Unit, Department of Molecular and Microbial Biosciences, University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia (VF, AWB, and JB-M); and the Department of Ophthalmology, National University of Singapore, Singapore, Republic of Singapore (TYW)
2 Supported by the Australian National Health and Medical Research Council.
3 Reprints not available. Address correspondence to P Mitchell, Department of Ophthalmology, University of Sydney, Centre for Vision Research, Westmead Millennium Institute, Westmead Hospital, Hawkesbury Road, Westmead, NSW Australia, 2145. E-mail: paul_mitchell{at}wmi.usyd.edu.au.
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
65 y. High-glycemic-index diets have been hypothesized as a risk factor for AMD, but prospective data are unavailable. Objective: The objective was to examine the association between dietary glycemic index and the 10-y incidence of AMD in the Blue Mountain Eye Study population.
Design: This was a population-based cohort study with 3654 participants (
49 y) examined at baseline (1992–1994); 2335 patients were reexamined after 5 y and 1952 after 10 y. The Wisconsin System was used to grade 10-y incident early and late AMD from retinal photographs. A food-frequency questionnaire was used to collect dietary information at baseline, and an Australian database was used to calculate the mean glycemic index.
Results: Over 10 y, 208 of 1810 persons (cumulative incidence: 14.1%) developed early AMD. After age, smoking, other risk factors, and dietary constituents were adjusted for, a higher mean dietary glycemic index was associated with an increased 10-y risk of early AMD in a comparison of quartiles 1 and 4 [relative risk (RR): 1.77; 95% CI: 1.13, 2.78; P for trend = 0.03]. Conversely, a greater consumption of cereal fiber (RR: 0.68; 95% CI: 0.44, 1.04; P for trend = 0.05) and breads and cereals (predominantly lower glycemic index foods such as oatmeal) (RR: 0.67; 95% CI: 0.44, 1.02; P for trend = 0.03) was associated with a reduced risk of incident early AMD. No relation was observed with late AMD.
Conclusions: A high-glycemic-index diet is a risk factor for early AMD—the recognized precursor of sight-threatening late AMD. Low-glycemic-index foods such as oatmeal may protect against early AMD.
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
50 y and is the most frequent cause of incurable blindness in the United States and elsewhere (1-3). AMD has early and late forms; early AMD is the precursor for sight-threatening late AMD. Dietary factors have long been implicated as possible risk factors for AMD. The Age-Related Eye Disease Study (AREDS) has shown that high-dose zinc and antioxidant supplementation have reduced the progression from early to late AMD (4, 5). However, few clinical trials have investigated the primary prevention of early AMD, and their findings have been equivocal (6, 7). Dietary glycemic index (GI) is commonly used to characterize the postprandial blood glucose response to the consumption of carbohydrates, which is now recognized as an important factor for cardiovascular disease (8, 9). The GI ranks carbohydrate quality from 0 (low glycemic response) to 100 (high glycemic response) on the basis of the blood glucose response 2 h after the consumption of 50 g of a carbohydrate food relative to the response after the consumption of 50 g of glucose (10). The index therefore provides a global summary measure of the rate of digestion and absorption of that carbohydrate food. Diets with a high GI are associated with an increased risk of coronary heart disease, stroke, and type 2 diabetes (11-14).
It is unknown whether high-GI diets are associated with risk of AMD. Two cross-sectional studies reported an association between dietary consumption of carbohydrates with higher GIs and AMD (15, 16), but prospective studies are lacking. In this population-based prospective cohort study, we examined the associations of dietary GI and long-term risk of AMD. We specifically investigated the independent effect of dietary fiber intake, given known interrelations between GI and fiber, (17) and also investigated food groups that could underlie potential associations.
| SUBJECTS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
49 y in the Blue Mountains, west of Sydney, Australia (Blue Mountain Eye Study). At baseline in 1992–1994, 3654 participants (82.4% response) were examined (18, 19). Participants were examined every 5 y; 2335 (75.1% of survivors) at the second examination in 1997–1999, and 1952 (76.5% of survivors) at the third in 2002–2004. The study complied with recommendations of the Helsinki Declaration and was approved by the Sydney West Area Health Service Human Research Ethics Committee. Written informed consent was obtained from all participants.
AMD definition
At each visit, 30° stereoscopic retinal photographs of the macula and other retinal fields of both eyes were taken, as described previously (18). Details of the photographic grading for AMD lesions were reported previously (18), which closely followed the Wisconsin Age-Related Maculopathy Grading System (20). All photographs taken at each examination had an initial masked grading. Assessments of inter- and intragrader reliability showed good agreement (18). Side-by-side grading of the baseline and 5-y photographs (21) and of the baseline and 10-y photographs was then performed for participants with any AMD lesions identified at either follow-up examination.
Early AMD was defined, in the absence of late AMD, as presence at the macula of either 1) large (>125 µm diameter) indistinct soft (or reticular) drusen or 2) both large distinct soft drusen and retinal pigmentary abnormalities (hyperpigmentation or hypopigmentation) (18, 22). Late AMD was defined to include either neovascular AMD or geographic atrophy—the 2 late-stage lesions described in the International AMD classification (22). All late AMD cases detected from each examination were adjudicated and confirmed by a retinal specialist (PM).
Incident early AMD was defined by new appearance of early AMD lesions at follow-up examinations (1). Participants with either distinct soft drusen or retinal pigmentary abnormalities at the baseline examination, but not both, who went on to develop complementary lesions that together made up early AMD were included as incident early AMD cases (1). Incident indistinct soft drusen or incident retinal pigmentary abnormalities were defined similarly among persons without early or late AMD. Incident late AMD was defined by the new appearance at follow-up of neovascular AMD or geographic atrophy.
Dietary assessment
A standardized interview and examination were performed, and participants completed a detailed 145-item food-frequency questionnaire (FFQ) modified for the Australian diet and vernacular from a Willett questionnaire (23), which incorporated a 9-category frequency scale and standard portion size estimates. This FFQ had reasonable concurrent validity when validated against 4-d weighed food records collected on 3 occasions in 1 y (n = 79) (24).
GI data were obtained from the Sydney University Glycemic Index Research Service (SUGiRS) online database (www.glycemicindex.com) and published values (25). In total, 88.9% of GI values were obtained from published values, and 11.1% were interpolated from similar food items. An overall GI value for each participant's diet was calculated by summating the weighted GI of individual foods in the diet, with the weighting proportional to the contribution of individual foods to total carbohydrate intake. We also extracted data on the fiber contribution from both breads and cereals.
Assessment of confounders
The interview included questions about past medical history, including physician-diagnosed history of stroke or myocardial infarction, and lifestyle factors such as smoking. Higher educational achievement was defined as attainment of qualifications (certificate, diploma, or degree) after leaving school. A single measure of systolic and diastolic blood pressure was recorded with the use of a mercury sphygmomanometer from the first and fifth Korotkoff sounds. Mean arterial blood pressure was defined as 0.33 x systolic blood pressure + 0.67 x diastolic blood pressure. Body mass index (BMI) was calculated as weight (kg) /height squared (m). Diabetes was defined on the basis of either past history of diabetes and current diabetes treatment or a fasting plasma glucose concentration
7.0 mmol/L at examination according to the World Health Organization diabetes classification (26). Fasting blood samples were processed on the same day for white cell count, total cholesterol, and HDL cholesterol by the Institute of Clinical Pathology and Medical Research, Westmead Hospital.
Study sample
The baseline cohort consisted of 3654 predominantly white participants who were aged
49 y, 43.3% of whom were men. At the 10-y follow-up examinations, there were 1952 participants: 1103 (30.2% of original cohort) of the participants had died, 375 (10.3%) had moved from the study area, and 224 (6.1%) refused to participate. Retinal photographs were obtained for both eyes in 98%, or for at least one eye in 99%, of the baseline and 5-y participants (21) and for both eyes in 85% (1649/1952), or for at least one eye in 87% (1689/1952), of the 10-y participants. Those lost to follow-up tended to be younger, to have a lower socioeconomic status, and to smoke, but were less likely to have coronary heart disease (21).
The FFQ was attempted and returned by 3267 baseline participants (89.4%); 2897 (79.3% of total participants) had sufficiently complete and plausible FFQ data for analysis. Subjects were excluded if >12 questions were missing, if an entire page remained blank, or if daily energy intakes were <2500 kJ or >18 000 kJ (24, 27). Participants without usable FFQ data were more likely to be older (mean age: 69.3 y compared with 65.3 y) or current smokers (17.7% compared with 14.2%) than were those with usable FFQs.
We initially conducted the analyses in the whole cohort and then excluded persons with diabetes on the basis that the GI of persons with diabetes is likely to be misclassified because of their unpredictable glycemic responses. The baseline study sample thus consisted of 2641 participants (72.3%) who had reliable dietary assessment data, had gradable fundus photographs, had participated in at least one follow-up examination, and did not have diabetes.
Statistical methods
Statistical analyses were performed by using SAS (version 9; SAS Institute, Cary, NC). We examined the association between baseline mean dietary GI, consumption of carbohydrates and fiber, and specific foods and the 10-y incidence of both early and late AMD. GI, carbohydrate, and fiber variables were adjusted for total energy intake by using the Willett residual method (28). Subject intakes were divided into quartiles for GI, macronutrients, and food groups.
Person-specific incidence rates were calculated by using Kaplan-Meier product-limit survival estimates to incorporate information from the 5- and 10-y examinations. Cumulative incidence was estimated by subtracting the Kaplan-Meier estimate from one and expressed as a percentage. Discrete linear logistic models were used to assess relations between dietary variables and incident early or late AMD at either of the 2 follow-up time points. The following potential confounders were considered: age, sex, mean arterial blood pressure, BMI, smoking, HDL cholesterol, post–secondary school qualifications, past history of coronary heart disease or stroke, and consumption of fish, total vegetables, fruit, and total fat. Micronutrient variables, vitamins C and E, β-carotene, zinc, lutein, zeaxanthin, and folate replaced total vegetables, fruit, and total fat in alternative models. Relative risks (RRs) and 95% CIs are presented.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
|
20% of the participants did not have this blood test performed. Stratification by age showed that in persons younger than 70 y (at the baseline examination), the relation between early AMD and GI (quartile 4 versus quartile 1, 78% increased risk of early AMD) or cereal fiber (quartile 4 compared with quartile 1: 54% reduced risk of early AMD) was strengthened and remained significant. In persons aged >70 y, the results were markedly attenuated, with no trends demonstrated, and became nonsignificant.
Multivariate-adjusted associations between mean dietary GI, cereal fiber, consumption of breads and cereals, and the 10-y incidence of indistinct soft drusen and pigmentary abnormalities—the 2 cardinal signs of early AMD—are shown in Table 4
. The highest compared with the lowest quartile of mean dietary GI at the baseline examination predicted a 68% higher 10-y risk of indistinct soft drusen (P for trend = 0.04). The highest compared with the lowest quartile of cereal fiber (P for trend = 0.01) and breads and cereal consumption (P for trend = 0.04) predicted a 39% and 47% reduction, respectively, in the 10-y risk of indistinct soft drusen. A relatively similar reduction (by 39% or 31%) in the 10-y risk of retinal pigmentary abnormalities was predicted by the highest quartile of cereal fiber (P for trend = 0.04) and breads and cereal consumption (P for trend = 0.04).
|
: 60.3 g/d) was substantially greater than the mean consumption of other breakfast cereals (
: 32.9 g/d). Similarly, the mean consumption of whole-meal/mixed-grain bread (
: 48.0 g/d) was greater than for white bread—a relatively high-GI food (
: 23.1 g/d). Overall carbohydrate consumption was not associated with the incidence of early AMD or its component lesions. No significant relations were found between total dietary fiber and its separate vegetable fiber or fruit fiber components or between individual vegetable or fruit consumption and the incidence of early AMD or its component lesions. No significant associations were found between the mean dietary GI of foods consumed, cereal fiber, carbohydrates, and the 10-y incidence of late AMD (data not shown).
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The calculated GI of carbohydrates is commonly used to determine its "dietary value," because carbohydrates are critical macronutrients that influence insulin secretion and postprandial glycemia, now known to be important factors in the pathogenesis of diabetes and cardiovascular disease. Consistent with this hypothesis, we found no association between total consumption of carbohydrates and risk of early AMD, which suggested that it is not the quantity of carbohydrates per se but possibly their postprandial effects that are important.
Our results are based on the exclusion of persons with diabetes. Analysis of the entire cohort attenuated the significance level of findings. It is likely that the inclusion of persons with diabetes led to some misclassification in GI, which tended to bias our results toward the null. Persons with diabetes are likely to have unpredictable glycemic responses, which makes it difficult to classify these subjects on the basis of glycemic values extrapolated from persons without diabetes.
To the best of our knowledge, only 2 studies, both of which were cross-sectional, have examined this relation. The Nurses' Health Study found that the mean dietary GI was related to pigmentary abnormalities but not to drusen (15). However, we found no significant prospective association between GI and long-term risk of pigmentary abnormalities. The reasons for the difference in findings with our study are unclear, although one reason may have been the different study methods, particularly different AMD definitions, used. Analysis of AREDS data showed a relation between large drusen and the highest quintile of GI as well as a positive relation between mean GI and an increasing severity of disease (16).
Our findings have a sound biological basis. Early signs of AMD, such as soft drusen, may result from oxidative damage in the light- and oxygen-rich milieu of the retina (29) or from inflammation and activation of the complement cascade (30, 31). It is possible that either or both of these 2 pathogenic mechanisms may be activated by higher-GI diets. Normal levels of glycemia tend to depress plasma antioxidant capacity (32) and hyperglycemia has been shown to generate oxidative stress (33-36). In diabetes, the oxidative stress generated by hyperglycemia has been shown to activate all pathways leading to diabetes complications, including the polyol and hexosamine pathways, the formation of advanced glycation end products, and the activation of protein kinase C (33). For AMD, it seems likely that oxidative stress results in protein modifications that contribute to the development of drusen (37, 38). In relation to inflammation, a recent study showed that a high-glycemic-load diet predicted higher concentrations of C-reactive protein—an inflammatory mediator also found in drusen.(30, 39).
Evidence of a role for advanced glycosylation end products (AGEs) in AMD pathobiology is also accumulating. AGEs are important pathological byproducts of hyperglycemia and have been found to accumulate in the outer retina with increasing age (40). Higher AGE concentrations are found in persons with AMD and are also a component of drusen (40). It is thought that the vascular endothelium is exquisitely sensitive to hyperglycemia because of its inability to control glucose transport across the membrane (33). AGEs accumulate in the endothelium and contribute to both endothelial dysfunction and permeability, a mechanism proposed for the increased risk of stroke in persons consuming high-GI diets (41). Recent studies have shown links between stroke, cardiovascular disease, and AMD; one of the possible mechanisms may be hyperglycemia-induced damage to the vascular endothelium (42, 43).
We showed that cereal fiber consumption reduced the long-term risk of early AMD. To our knowledge, this association has not been investigated previously. Cereal fiber can also reduce the glycemic response to subsequent meals by a second-meal effect (44). Lower levels of postprandial glycemia may thus represent a common mechanism for the beneficial effects observed from both GI and cereal fiber.
The strengths of our study include its prospective nature, long-term follow-up of a stable population-based sample, reasonable follow-up time, use of high-quality stereoscopic retinal photography with validated grading to assess macular conditions (including side-by-side comparisons of the baseline and follow-up examination photographs), and reliable categorization of the GI of a wide range of Australian foods, which contrasts with other studies in which this index was largely extrapolated (25).
Our study had several limitations. We had insufficient power to show relations between mean GI and the incidence of late AMD. A relatively high proportion of participants with missing FFQ data were likely to be older and current smokers. This may explain the lack of baseline differences between participants with and without incident AMD, because the missing data might have diluted the associations observed since smokers and older persons were more likely to have AMD.
Because healthy behaviors, such as not smoking and greater fruit and vegetable consumption, were associated with diets with a lower mean GI in our study (Table 1
), the overall GI of foods consumed by individuals may be a marker for healthy dietary and lifestyle patterns rather than be representative of a causal pathway. Persons consume a combination of various foods simultaneously, but not in isolation. However our analyses address the associations of AMD with food components in relative isolation, with adjustment for energy and only a limited number of other food elements and lifestyle factors. Additionally, people potentially change their diets over time, and our dietary data, collected at one point in time, likely suffer from a range of measurement errors. It remains a challenge to nutritional epidemiologists to summarize and group patterns of dietary intake and also cover all aspects of diet. Currently, there are no widely accepted approaches in this regard. We attempted to address some of these issues by controlling for many dietary and lifestyle factors in the analysis. We also excluded persons who were likely to have modified their diets, such as persons with diabetes, who may also have unpredictable glycemic responses to similar foods compared with the general population. We believe that our study findings need to be validated by future studies using better approaches to eliminate potential residual confounding effects. Support for our study findings at this stage, however, arises from the consistency of the findings across the 3 studies that include both cross-sectional and longitudinal observations —the present study and 2 others (15, 16).
Finally, in our population, a higher GI was associated with an increase in stroke-related mortality (although not all-cause or coronary heart disease mortality). Although survival bias could have diluted our results, this effect is likely to be relatively modest because the number of stroke deaths was small (n = 95).
Early AMD is the major predictor of progression to late AMD, and few effective preventive or therapeutic strategies that target these early signs are available (29, 45, 46). Primary prevention of early AMD lesions will substantially reduce the number of persons who develop sight-threatening late AMD. Whereas antioxidant supplements may delay progression from early to late AMD (5), the findings of other randomized controlled trials on the primary prevention of early AMD have been equivocal (6, 7). Our study, therefore, has potential implications for the prevention of early AMD in the population.
In summary, we showed that a diet with a high mean GI is a risk factor for early AMD. Conversely, specific foods, such as cereal fiber, may reduce the risk of early AMD. Our findings require replication in prospective studies in other populations. AMD is currently responsible for
14 million cases of blindness or severe visual impairment worldwide (47). Given its significant public health impact, recommendations to consume lower-GI diets may help prevent AMD on a population-wide basis.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
JBM is a coauthor of The New Glucose Revolution book series (Hodder and Stoughton, New York, NY), is the Director of a not-for-profit GI-based food endorsement program in Australia, and manages the University of Sydney GI testing service. AB is a coauthor of one of these books: Diabetes & Pre-diabetes Handbook and is a consultant to a not-for-profit GI-based food endorsement program in Australia. None of the other authors had a conflict of interest to declare. All authors declare their independence from the funding body (The Australian National Health and Medical Research Council), which had no role in the study design, the collection, analysis, the interpretation of the data, the writing of the report, or the decision to submit the paper for publication.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |